Operational Resilience Audit

Emerging Trends in Operational Resilience Auditing: A 2024 Report

Operational resilience has become a top priority for organizations across industries, prompting the rise of specialized auditing practices.

This report explores key emerging trends shaping the landscape of operational resilience auditing in 2024.

1. Increased Regulatory Scrutiny

Regulatory bodies worldwide are implementing stricter requirements for operational resilience, mandating regular audits and stress testing exercises. This drives demand for skilled auditors familiar with relevant regulatory frameworks.

2. Focus on Third-Party Risk Management

Modern businesses' interconnectedness amplifies third-party vulnerabilities' impact. Audits increasingly scrutinize third-party contracts, risk management procedures, and control environments to ensure supply chain resilience.

3. Integration with Cybersecurity Audits

The convergence of cyber and operational risks necessitates combined audits examining IT infrastructure, data security, and incident response capabilities alongside traditional operational resilience assessments.

4. Adoption of Technology-Assisted Auditing

Advanced analytics, artificial intelligence (AI), and automation are transforming how audits are conducted. These tools enable auditors to analyze vast datasets, identify hidden patterns, and streamline data collection, freeing time for deeper analysis and judgment.

5. Shift Towards Scenario-Based Testing

Static assessments give way to dynamic scenario-based testing that simulates real-world disruptions. This approach helps organizations refine their resilience plans and identify vulnerabilities under pressure.

6. Evolving Threat Landscape

Auditors must stay informed about emerging threats like climate change, geopolitical instability, and cyberattacks, continuously adapting their methodologies to address these dynamic risks.

7. Growing Demand for Skilled Professionals

The burgeoning field of operational resilience auditing creates a talent gap.

Training and certification programs are crucial to upskill existing professionals and attract new talent to meet the rising demand.

8. Emphasis on Business Continuity Management (BCM) Integration

Effective operational resilience relies on integrating resilience principles into existing BCM frameworks.

Auditors focus on ensuring BCM programs align with organizational objectives and address emerging threats.

9. Continuous Improvement and Learning

Operational resilience is an ongoing journey, not a destination.

Audits should emphasize the importance of continuous improvement, learning from incidents, and adapting resilience plans based on evolving threats and organizational changes.

10. International Collaboration and Harmonization

Harmonization across jurisdictions and industries is critical as regulations and best practices evolve.

International collaboration among regulators, auditors, and professional bodies is gaining momentum to facilitate knowledge sharing and consistent approaches.

By staying informed about these trends, audit professionals can adapt their practices, embrace new technologies, and contribute to building robust and adaptable operational resilience for organizations in the face of ever-changing risks.

	Please feel free to send us a note if you have any of these questions.

What Are You Required to Complete for  Module 1 of the ORA-300 Programme?

Module 1: E-Learning

To complete Module 1 of the ORA-300 Operational Resilience Audit Specialist (ORAS) course.

Module 1 of the OR Audit Specialist/ Expert Course

Module 1 is the first of the [1] four-module for the ORA-5000 Blended Learning (BL-ORA-5) [2] two-module ORA-300 Blended Learning (BL-ORA-3) or [3] stand-alone module for the ORA-200 Blended Learning (BL-ORA-2) course.

Participants must attend a walk-through of one introduction to operational resilience (OR) and another module of the OR Implementation process. 

Learning Modules: Fundamentals of Operational Resilience Audit

1. Overview of Operational Resilience
2. Operational Resilience Terminology and Related Concepts
3. Operational Resilience Planning Methodology
4. Identify Critical Business Services
5. Map Processes and Resources
6. Set Impact Tolerance
7. Conduct Scenario Testing
8. Improve Lesson Learnt

The participant is required to spend about 1 hour per E-Learning sub-module

Note that Module 1 is also Module 1 (of 4) for participants attending the Blended Learning ORA-5000 course [BL-ORA-5] leading to the Operational Resilience Audit Expert (ORAE). At the same time, it is also Module 1 (of 2) for the Blended Learning ORA-300 [BL-ORA-3] leading to Operational Resilience Audit Specialist (ORAS).

Lastly, Module 1 can also be taken as a stand-alone OR-200 or BL-OR-2 course leading to Operational Resilience Certified Planner (ORCP).

The participant is required to spend about 8 hours. 

Click the "Course Content" button to learn more about this module's syllabus.

 

More Information About Blended Learning Operational Resilience Audit (ORA) Courses

BCM Institute offers two levels of OR auditing courses: ORA-3 Blended Learning ORA-300 Operational Resilience Audit Specialist and the ORA-5 Blended Learning ORA-5000 Operational Resilience Audit Expert.

	Please feel free to send us a note if you have any questions.

Module 3: Online Training and Discussion Workshop

To complete Module 3, participants must attend two half-day sessions of the OR audit implementation process. These are:

Before attending each of the two separate  1/2-day facilitated online workshops, the typical activities to complete the assignment are:

• developing the audit program or checklist;
• reviewing the stages of a typical BCM Audit planning process
• having access to the live BCMS portal.

Sequence of A Walkthrough of Each Session

1. Pre-reading [Maximum of one hour]
   • Review the OR planning methodology
   • Review the content of the BCMPedia for OR and OR Audit

1. Attending Facilitated Online Workshop [Maximum of three-hour]
   • Review and discuss the issues and challenges in developing an audit program (Financial / IT) or checklist
     

The content of Module 3 can be found by clicking on the "Course Content" icon.

[M3-S2] What is expected from Session 2 [S2] for Module 3 [M3] consists of the following:

1. Pre-reading  [Maximum of one hour]
   • OR Audit Planning Process [4 ten-minute articles]
     
     
2. Download the "Standardise Audit Program" template and complete the template [Maximum of one hour]
   
   • Develop an audit questionnaire in the audit checklist
     • You are strongly encouraged to attempt two significant stages of the "Implement" phase   as practice before attending class
       
       
3. Facilitated Online Workshop [Maximum of three hours]
   • Guide the review of the key deliverable of the BCM Audit planning process
   • Develop audit checklist/ program using the Standardise Audit Program template.
     
     

Pre-readings of at least 8 to 10 blogs or articles located in the eCampus are assigned for each session. Participants are recommended to complete them before the session as it serves as  'bite-sized' background information, allowing participants to familiarize themselves with the concepts to be discussed. 

It would also assist participants in completing their assignment in the following  1 hour online session.

[M3-S2] Once the schedule for the specific phase is confirmed, you will be notified to proceed to download the Audit Checklist template.  

Develop OR Audit Questionnaire within the Audit Program/ Checklist Template (Assignment) Before Attending the Facilitated Online Workshop

What if you are completing the form and do not understand the purpose or requirement of the field that you are completing?

Reference Guide: Refer to "A Manager's Guide to Review and Audit Your Operation Resilience Program [LITE]" and "A Manager's Guide to Implement Your Operation Resilience" as they provide a reasonably comprehensive explanation for each field as required in the template.

Sample Questionnaires: For auditor/ lead auditor course attendees, you are provided with a complete series of sample questions for all the clauses to assist you in developing the BM Audit questionnaires as "Pre-reading" titled Audit Questionnaires: Table of Content.

Objectives

The objective is to fully understand the purpose and requirements of each entry in the template before you attend the corresponding online workshop.

You may wonder why you are doing the assignment when the lesson has not yet been conducted.

It will also allow you to contextualize your business environment and ask related questions.

 

[M3-S2] Attend Facilitated Online Workshop

 

For the Module 3 course, participants must attend two 3-hour online workshop sessions.  All sessions are compulsory and run at the pre-determined online schedule. There would not be a repeat or substitute session for anyone who missed it.

These are the key features and deliverables of Module 3:

1. Develop OR Audit Program/ Checklist
2. Understand the OR Audit Planning Process 

Submit your completed "Audit Checklist" template to the facilitator within two days after finishing the Facilitated Online session M3-S2.  Do note that you should have completed version 1 of this template before you attend the Online session. 

 

Time Requirement

Module 3: Session 1 & 2

Three Hour (Per Session)

 

Breakdown of Time Spent

Here is a breakdown of the time spent for Module 3 for two 3-hour per session.

 

Module	Mode of Study	Hours
M3-S1	Web Training and Discussion Workshop 1-Hour Self Study (Pre-reading and review of the case study) 3-Hour Schedule Online Classes	4
M3-S2	Web Training and Discussion Workshop 1-Hour Self Study (Pre-reading and review of the case study) 1-Hour Preparation Assignment to complete the Audit Questionnaires 3-Hour Schedule Online Classes	5
	Total Hours	9

More Information About Blended Learning Operational Resilience Audit (ORA) Courses

BCM Institute offers two levels of OR auditing courses: ORA-3 or ORA-300 Operational Resilience Audit Specialist and the ORA-5 or ORA-5000 Operational Resilience Audit Expert.

Please feel free to send us a note if you have any questions.

 

Internal vs External OR Auditing: Roles, Responsibilities and Ethics

While internal and external auditors contribute to assessing and strengthening operational resilience, their roles, responsibilities, and ethical considerations differ significantly.

Hence, it is helpful to understand the differences in roles, responsibilities and ethical considerations between IA and EA.

Internal Auditors (IA)

Roles of IA

• Independent assurance provider. Evaluating the effectiveness of existing resilience programs and controls within the organization.
• Risk consultant. Collaborating with business units to identify and mitigate operational risks impacting resilience.
• Process improvement advocate. Proposing recommendations to enhance OR posture and optimize processes.
• Change agent. Driving improvements in risk management culture and awareness across the organization.

Responsibilities of IA

• Conducting risk assessments and audits focused on operational resilience.
  Testing controls and processes designed to mitigate identified risks.
• Evaluating the adequacy and effectiveness of resilience plans and preparedness.
• Reporting findings and recommendations to management and relevant stakeholders.
• Monitoring and measuring the effectiveness of implemented improvements.

Ethical Considerations of IA

• Maintaining independence and objectivity: Avoiding undue influence from management or bias towards specific outcomes.
• Confidentiality: Protecting sensitive information obtained during audits while ensuring adequate reporting for oversight purposes.
• Competence and professional diligence: Continuously updating knowledge and skills to perform audits effectively and adhere to professional standards.
• Acting in the organisation's best interests: Balancing adherence to regulations with supporting the organization's long-term sustainability and ethical conduct.

External Auditors (EA)

Roles of EA

• Independent opinion provider: Offering an external perspective on the organization's overall risk management and resilience posture.
• Regulatory compliance assurer: Verifying adherence to relevant regulations and standards impacting operational resilience.
• Stakeholder assurance provider: Building confidence for investors, creditors, and other stakeholders regarding the organization's resilience capabilities.

Responsibilities of EA

• Conducting audits focused on specific regulatory requirements or contractual obligations related to operational resilience.
• Assessing the design and effectiveness of controls based on agreed-upon procedures.
• Reporting findings and opinions to relevant stakeholders, potentially including public disclosure.
• May not delve as deeply into operational details as internal auditors.

Ethical Considerations of EA

• Maintaining independence and objectivity. Avoiding conflicts of interest and undue influence from clients or regulators.
• Professional scepticism. Maintaining a critical questioning stance ensures audit conclusions are based on accurate and sufficient evidence.
• Confidentiality. Protecting sensitive information obtained during audits while fulfilling reporting requirements to designated parties.
• Communication and transparency. Communicating limitations and uncertainties associated with their audit findings and opinions.

Key Differences

• Focus.  Internal auditors focus on broader operational resilience within the organisation, while external auditors may have a narrower scope dictated by regulations or contracts.
• Reporting. Internal auditors report primarily to management and internal stakeholders, while external auditors report to their clients and potentially publicly.
• Depth of engagement. Internal auditors typically understand the organisation's internal workings and may conduct more in-depth assessments.
• Impact. Internal auditors directly impact internal change and improvement within the organisation, while external auditors provide assurance and may trigger regulatory consequences.

Collaboration and Coordination

While their roles and responsibilities differ, effective operational resilience relies on collaboration and coordination between internal and external auditors.

• Sharing information and insights. Internal auditors can provide external auditors valuable context and understanding of the organisation's operations and risk landscape.
• Joint assessments. In some cases, collaborative audits can leverage the strengths of both parties for a more comprehensive evaluation.
• Mutual respect and understanding. Recognising the value each type of auditor brings to building a robust operational resilience framework.

By understanding internal and external auditors' different roles, responsibilities, and ethical considerations, organisations can effectively leverage their combined expertise to assess and strengthen their operational resilience posture.

	Please feel free to send us a note if you have any of these questions.

Roles and Responsibilities of Operational Resilience Auditors

Operational resilience auditors ensure organisations can withstand disruptions and maintain critical operations. Their responsibilities involve diverse tasks, requiring a unique blend of technical expertise, communication skills, and problem-solving abilities.

Here is a breakdown of their key roles and responsibilities:

Assessment and Evaluation

• Identify and assess potential threats.   
  • Analyse various sources to understand internal and external factors that could disrupt critical operations.
    
    
• Evaluate existing resilience programs. 
  • Assess the effectiveness of existing controls, plans, and processes in mitigating identified risks.
    
    
• Perform risk assessments. 
  • Utilise various methodologies (e.g., scenario-based, data-driven) to quantify the likelihood and impact of potential disruptions.
    
    
• Conduct audits and investigations.
  • Analyse documentation, interview stakeholders, and test controls to evaluate program effectiveness and identify vulnerabilities.

Planning and Implementation

• Develop and recommend improvements. 
  • Based on their findings, propose enhancements to existing programs, controls, and processes.
    
    
• Collaborate with stakeholders. 
  • Engage with business units, risk management teams, and senior leadership to understand needs and ensure aligned recommendations.
    
    
• Develop and implement audit plans. 
  • Design the scope, objectives, and methodologies for conducting operational resilience audits.
    
    
• Manage and lead audit teams. 
  • Build, train, and motivate teams with diverse skill sets to achieve audit objectives effectively.

Communication and Reporting

• Communicate effectively. 
  • Present audit findings and recommendations clearly and concisely to various stakeholders, tailored to their needs and knowledge level.
    
    
• Prepare audit reports. 
  • Draft comprehensive and actionable reports documenting findings, conclusions, and recommendations, adhering to relevant standards and regulations.
    
    
• Facilitate discussion and action. 
  • Collaborate with stakeholders to address concerns, answer questions, and implement agreed-upon actions.

Continuous Improvement and Development

• Monitor and update assessments.
  • Keep updated with evolving threats, regulatory changes, and industry best practices, and refine assessments and recommendations accordingly.
    
    
• Stay informed about emerging trends. 
  • Learn and adapt continuously to new technologies, techniques, and methodologies in operational resilience auditing.
    
    
• Share knowledge and expertise. 
  • Contribute to the profession's development by sharing best practices, participating in professional organisations, and mentoring others.

Additional Responsibilities and Specific Role

• Third-party risk assessments. 
  • Evaluate the resilience of critical vendors and suppliers.
    
    
• Regulatory compliance audits. 
  • Ensure adherence to relevant regulations impacting operational resilience.
    
    
• Information security audits. 
  • Assess the cybersecurity posture of systems and controls related to operational resilience.

Summing Up ...

Overall, operational resilience auditors are critical in protecting organisations from disruptions and ensuring business continuity.

They require a comprehensive skill set, critical thinking abilities, and the ability to effectively communicate complex information to diverse stakeholders.

As the field evolves, their responsibilities will continue to adapt and expand, requiring continuous learning and development to address emerging challenges and effectively contribute to organisational resilience.

	Please feel free to send us a note if you have any of these questions.