[OR] [P2] [S4] [ST] [C3] Types of Exercises (Integrated BCM & Crisis Management)

Chapter 3

Types of Exercises (Integrated BCM & Crisis Management)

Introduction

Exercises are the practical means by which organizations validate their Business Continuity Management (BCM) and Crisis Management (CM) capabilities. While plans and strategies provide the blueprint for resilience, it is through structured exercises that organisations determine whether those plans can be executed effectively under real-world conditions.

In an Operational Resilience (OR) context, exercises must go beyond isolated testing of recovery procedures or crisis communication. They must simulate end-to-end disruption scenarios that test:

• The organisation’s ability to recover operations (BCM)
• The effectiveness of leadership, escalation, and communication (Crisis Management)
• The continuity of Critical Business Services (CBS) within the impact tolerance

This chapter explores the different types of exercises, how they integrate BCM and Crisis Management requirements, and how organisations can design a layered exercise programme to progressively build resilience capability.

Purpose of the Chapter

This chapter aims to:

• Define the major types of exercises used in BCM and Crisis Management
• Explain how each type contributes to resilience validation
• Guide when and how to use each exercise type
• Demonstrate how to integrate exercises into a cohesive programme
• Align exercise types with operational resilience objectives

Overview of Exercise Types

Exercises can be categorised based on their complexity, scope, and objectives. Each type serves a distinct purpose and contributes to a progressive maturity model.

Exercise Continuum

Exercises typically evolve along the following continuum:

A mature organisation uses a combination of exercise types, rather than relying on a single approach.

Walkthrough Exercises

Definition

Walkthrough exercises are structured sessions where participants review plans and procedures step-by-step.

BCM Focus

• Review of Business Continuity Plans (BCPs)
• Validation of roles, responsibilities, and recovery steps
• Identification of gaps in documentation

Crisis Management Focus

• Familiarisation with the Crisis Management Team (CMT) structure
• Review of escalation protocols
• Understanding communication flows

Benefits and Limitations

Benefits:

• Low cost and easy to conduct
• Useful for onboarding and awareness

Limitations:

• Limited realism
• Does not test decision-making under pressure

Tabletop Exercises

Definition

Tabletop exercises are discussion-based simulations where participants respond to a hypothetical scenario guided by a facilitator.

BCM Objectives

• Test activation of BCPs
• Validate coordination between business units
• Identify recovery challenges

Crisis Management Objectives

• Test decision-making and escalation
• Evaluate crisis communication strategies
• Assess leadership alignment

Key Features

• Scenario-based discussions
• Use of injectables to introduce new developments
• Facilitated environment

Best Use Cases

• Testing Crisis Management Team readiness
• Exploring new or complex scenarios
• Engaging senior leadership

Functional Exercises

Definition

Functional exercises test specific capabilities or functions without simulating the full organisational response.

BCM Focus

• Disaster Recovery (DR) testing
• System failover and data restoration
• Call tree and communication testing
• Alternate site activation

Crisis Management Focus

• Testing specific communication channels
• Verifying notification procedures

Benefits

• Validates technical and operational readiness
• Provides measurable results (e.g., RTO, RPO achievement)

Limitations

• Does not test the integrated response
• Limited insight into leadership decision-making

Simulation Exercises

Definition

Simulation exercises create realistic, dynamic environments where participants respond to evolving scenarios in real time.

BCM Objectives

• Test execution of recovery strategies
• Validate resource mobilisation
• Assess coordination across teams

Crisis Management Objectives

• Test real-time decision-making under pressure
• Evaluate communication with stakeholders
• Assess crisis escalation and governance

Key Characteristics

• Time-bound and fast-paced
• Use of multiple injects and evolving conditions
• High participant engagement

Example

A cyberattack simulation may involve:

• System outages requiring DR activation (BCM)
• Media inquiries requiring response (CM)
• Regulatory reporting requirements (CM)

Full-Scale Exercises

Definition

Full-scale exercises are the most comprehensive type, involving real-world deployment of resources and end-to-end testing.

7.2 BCM Focus

• Activation of recovery sites
• Physical relocation of staff
• End-to-end process recovery

Crisis Management Focus

• Full activation of the Crisis Management Team
• Real-time communication with stakeholders
• Coordination with external agencies

Operational Resilience Focus

• Validation of Critical Business Services delivery
• Testing interdependencies across systems and third parties

Benefits

• Provides the highest level of assurance
• Identifies systemic weaknesses

Challenges

• Resource-intensive
• Complex to plan and execute

Hybrid Exercises (Integrated BCM & CM)

Definition

Hybrid exercises combine elements of multiple exercise types to test both:

• Operational recovery (BCM)
• Strategic response (Crisis Management)

Example

A hybrid exercise may include:

• Tabletop crisis decision-making (CM)
• Simultaneous DR testing (BCM)
• Real-time scenario escalation

Benefits

• Provides a holistic view of organisational resilience
• Bridges the gap between technical and strategic testing

Designing an Integrated Exercise Programme

Layered Approach

Organisations should adopt a progressive exercise strategy:

1. Walkthrough → Build awareness
2. Tabletop → Test decision-making
3. Functional → Validate capabilities
4. Simulation → Test integrated response
5. Full-scale → Validate end-to-end resilience

Alignment with BCM & CM Objectives

Each exercise type should map to:

• BCM: Recovery validation (RTO, RPO, BCP effectiveness)
• CM: Leadership, escalation, communication
• OR: CBS continuity and impact tolerance

Frequency and Coverage

• High-criticality services: More frequent and complex exercises
• Inclusion of third parties and external stakeholders
• Coverage of diverse risk scenarios

Common Challenges in Exercise Execution

Over-Reliance on Tabletop Exercises

Limits the validation of actual recovery capability.

Lack of Integration

BCM and Crisis Management were tested separately.

Insufficient Realism

Scenarios do not reflect real-world complexity.

Limited Leadership Participation

Reduces the effectiveness of crisis exercises.

Best Practices for Effective Exercises

• Integrate BCM and Crisis Management objectives
• Use realistic, evolving scenarios
• Engage senior leadership and cross-functional teams
• Include third-party participation where relevant
• Define clear success criteria and metrics
• Capture lessons learned and drive improvements

Exercises are essential for transforming plans into real-world capability. Each exercise type plays a distinct role in building organisational resilience—from basic awareness to full-scale validation.

By adopting a layered and integrated exercise programme, organisations can:

• Validate recovery strategies (BCM)
• Strengthen crisis leadership and communication (CM)
• Ensure continuity of Critical Business Services (OR)

Ultimately, the effectiveness of an organisation’s resilience is not determined by the quality of its plans, but by its ability to execute under pressure. Exercises provide the environment where this capability is built, tested, and continuously improved.

C1	C2	C3	C4	C5	C6	C7
C8	C9	C10	C11	C12	C13

More Information About OR-5000 [OR-5] or OR-300 [OR-3]

To learn more about the course and schedule, click the buttons below for the OR-300 Operational Resilience Implementer course and the OR-5000 Operational Resilience Expert Implementer course.

	If you have any questions, click to contact us.