.
Building Resilient Operations: Implementing Business Continuity Management at Sands China
08_Restaurant_Service

[BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C9] Assessing Risks and Threats for Sands China Ltd

[BCM] [SANDS] [Full Banner] Implementing BCM at SANDS China

This chapter explains how SANDS can identify, analyse, evaluate and prioritise the risks of disruption to its prioritised activities and the resources they depend on. It builds on the context and methodology set out in Chapters 7 and 8 and feeds the business impact analysis (BIA) carried out in eBook 2, Implementing Business Continuity Management for Sands China Ltd. Its outputs also shape the continuity strategies and plans developed in eBooks 2 and 3. The chapter uses reference codes R1 to R12 for the illustrative risks and the critical business function (CBF) codes defined in Chapter 10.

[Logo] [BCM] Certification Transparent

Dr Goh Moh Heng

[BCM] [SANDS] [Full Banner] Implementing BCM at SANDS China

eBook 1: Chapter 2

New call-to-action

Introduction

Every integrated resort lives with risk, but not every resort knows which risks matter most. Sands China Ltd (SANDS) runs five resorts, a convention hall, large entertainment venues, hundreds of shops and a ferry service, all within one small city that has seen typhoons, power and water failures and government-ordered closures. A structured risk assessment tells SANDS where a disruption is most likely, where it would hurt most and what to do about it.

[BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C9] Assessing Risks and ThreatsThis chapter explains how SANDS can identify, analyse, evaluate and prioritise the risks of disruption to its prioritised activities and the resources they depend on. It builds on the context and methodology set out in Chapters 7 and 8 and feeds the business impact analysis (BIA) that eBook 2, Implementing Business Continuity Management for Sands China Ltd, carries out. Its outputs also shape the continuity strategies and plans developed in eBooks 2 and 3. The chapter uses reference codes R1 to R12 for the illustrative risks, and the critical business function (CBF) codes defined in Chapter 10.

Regulatory Alignment

The Macao Special Administrative Region (Macao SAR) Government is the primary regulatory authority for this series. No Macao business continuity rule specific to casino operators was identified in the research for this eBook, and none is assumed here. SANDS' risk assessment should therefore respond to the combined effect of several laws and directions that bear on disruption, and treat good practice as a benchmark where no formal rule exists.

The first is the gaming regime. The gaming law, Law No. 16/2001 as amended by Law No. 7/2022 [verify], gives the Gaming Inspection and Coordination Bureau (DICJ) supervisory powers over the six concessionaires. Press and legal commentary report that the 2022 reform introduced a fine range of MOP100,000 to MOP5 million and the possibility of temporarily closing gaming areas as an ancillary sanction.

Casinos must generally open every day, although operators may suspend operations in exceptional situations. In disasters, serious accidents or public safety risks, prior approval is reportedly not required, but operators must notify the government as soon as possible [verify]. A risk assessment should therefore test what happens if SANDS cannot open, and who tells the DICJ.

The second is civil protection. A new framework took effect on 15 September 2020 and allows the Chief Executive to order the temporary suspension of casino operations in an emergency [verify the law number].

The framework has been used in practice. Executive Order No. 141/2023 required gaming venues to close when a typhoon signal above No. 8 was announced during Typhoon Saola, and in 2025 the DICJ closed all casinos from the No. 8 signal during Super Typhoon Ragasa, with staff and patrons leaving in an orderly way within two hours before the signal took effect.

The third is cybersecurity and data. Macao's Cybersecurity Law (Law No. 13/2019), in force since December 2019, treats casinos and resorts as critical infrastructure according to press commentary [verify].

Private operators of critical infrastructure reportedly must maintain cybersecurity management arrangements, appoint a responsible person and report incidents to the Cybersecurity Incidents Alert and Response Centre. The Personal Data Protection Act (Law No. 8/2005) [verify] adds duties around guest data.

The fourth is listing. As a company listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange (HKEx code 1928), SANDS has governance, risk management and disclosure obligations under the listing rules [verify the specific provisions]. Board and senior management oversight of risk, including continuity, is therefore both a governance and a regulatory matter. Finally, SANDS' reliance on outsourced service providers and group shared services should be assessed against the same standard: a third-party failure is SANDS' disruption.

ISO 22301 Alignment

ISO 22301:2019 places disruption risk assessment in clause 8.2.3. It asks the organisation to establish, implement and maintain a risk assessment process that identifies, analyses and evaluates the risk of disruption to the organisation's prioritised activities and the resources they need. It also asks for risk treatment to be prioritised by the organisation's criteria.

The clause sits between two others. Clause 8.2.2, the BIA, identifies which activities matter and how fast they must recover. Clause 8.3, business continuity strategies and solutions, chooses how to protect and recover them. Risk assessment tells the strategy which threats to design against. In practice, the three clauses form a loop: the BIA names what to protect, the risk assessment says what threatens it, and the strategies close the gap.

A common source of confusion is the difference between clause 8.2.3 and clause 6.1. Clause 8.2.3 covers risks of disruption to operations: a flood, a cyber attack, a supplier failure. Clause 6.1 covers risks and opportunities to the BCMS itself: loss of management support, a shortage of trained coordinators, or the chance to link BCM to sustainability reporting. SANDS needs both, kept in separate registers so that operational and programme risks are not mixed.

ISO 31000:2018, the general risk management guideline, supports this work with a common vocabulary and process: establishing context, risk assessment (identification, analysis, evaluation), risk treatment, monitoring and communication. Aligning the BCM risk process with SANDS' wider enterprise risk framework avoids two competing risk languages.

A Methodology for SANDS

Scope, criteria and appetite

The assessment starts by confirming its scope: the five resorts, their services and the supporting functions covered in Chapter 8. SANDS then agrees its risk criteria, namely the scales used to rate likelihood and impact, and its risk appetite, the level of risk it accepts. The criteria should link to SANDS' enterprise risk management framework so that a "high" risk means the same thing in the BCM register and in the board's risk report.

For example, SANDS' leadership might decide that any risk that could endanger guest safety or breach the concession conditions is unacceptable above a given rating, regardless of financial impact. That rule would push risks such as fire in a crowded venue towards the top of the priority list even if they are rare.

Identifying threats and vulnerabilities

Identification links each threat to the resources a prioritised activity needs: people, premises, technology, information, suppliers and partners. A threat becomes a risk when it can exploit a vulnerability. A typhoon is a threat; a ground-level power installation exposed to flooding is a vulnerability. SANDS might discover through workshops, for example, that several resorts draw on a shared utility feed.

Analysing likelihood and impact

Analysis rates each risk on a defined scale for likelihood and impact, producing a score and a position on the risk matrix. Scales must be written down and applied consistently. The sample scales later in this chapter show the idea. Ratings should draw on evidence where possible, such as incident history, engineering assessments, supplier audits and the experience of past events in Macao.

Evaluating and treating risks

Evaluation compares each rating with the criteria to decide which risks need treatment and in what order. Treatment options are to avoid the risk, reduce it, transfer it (for example through insurance or contract terms) or accept it with approval. Treatment decisions feed directly into the continuity strategies of clause 8.3. Reducing a utility risk, for instance, might mean extra generator capacity, which then becomes part of the facilities strategy.

Single points of failure, concentration and dependencies

SANDS' interconnected Cotai footprint, shared systems and common suppliers create concentration. A single point of failure is any one component whose loss halts an activity: a data centre, a power feed, a payment gateway, a key person. Concentration risk arises when many activities depend on the same supplier or location. SANDS might also rely on its parent group for technology, procurement or other shared services. List those dependencies, review their continuity arrangements, and treat their failure as a disruption scenario.

Register, owners and review

The output is a risk register with a named owner for each risk, a record of controls and treatments, and a review date. SANDS should review high risks at least quarterly in the early stages and the whole register at least annually, as well as after any major incident or change, such as a new resort opening or a change in government rules.

Workshops and interviews

Risk assessment works best when the people who run operations take part. SANDS' BCM coordinator can convene workshops with resort operations, engineering, technology, security, human resources, procurement and legal and compliance, supplemented by interviews with executives and key suppliers. A good workshop starts from a specific scenario, such as a No. 8 signal at 4 pm on a busy Saturday, and walks through what would fail.

SANDS' Threat Landscape

The threat landscape below is tailored to SANDS' sector and to Macao. It gives most weight to the categories where Macao experience is strongest.

Natural hazards

Typhoons dominate. Typhoon Hato struck on 23 August 2017 with winds above 200 km/h, and the Macao government described it as the strongest storm recorded in the city in 53 years. SANDS told the press that its properties were hit by a power and water outage, that backup generators functioned as designed, yet operations and customer service were affected.

The DICJ asked casino operators to suspend gaming at any venue that had lost power. In September 2018, Super Typhoon Mangkhut led to a 33-hour industry-wide suspension of gaming.

Closures also followed Typhoons Saola (2023) and Ragasa (2025). Flooding and storm surge accompany these events, and Amendment 1:2024 to ISO 22301 prompts SANDS to consider whether climate change makes them more frequent or severe.

Utilities and infrastructure

Hato showed how dependent the city is on power, water and telecommunications. Reports at the time noted that parts of Macao were without power or water for an extended period. SANDS' resorts rely on backup generation, but backup systems have limits in capacity, fuel and coverage. Utility failure is therefore a risk in its own right, not merely a consequence of typhoons.

Public-health and government-ordered closures

All casinos closed for 15 days from 5 February 2020, and again for a week from 11 July 2022, to contain COVID-19. These events involved no physical damage, yet halted core revenue. Future public-health events could produce similar orders, together with staff absence and changes in visitor movement.

Cyber-attacks and data breaches

SANDS' guest, gaming and payment systems are attractive targets. Ransomware, intrusion into hotel or loyalty systems and attacks on suppliers are all credible. Macao's Cybersecurity Law adds reporting and management duties [verify]. Sector cyber incidents should be reviewed in workshops to calibrate likelihood [verify examples].

Systems and equipment

Failures in gaming platforms, hotel property management, payment processing, building management, or surveillance systems can interrupt service and breach regulatory expectations for surveillance and cash handling. Single points of failure are common here.

Suppliers, tenants and cross-border access

SANDS depends on food, equipment, technology and maintenance suppliers, and on retail tenants. Guests and team members also depend on cross-border and ferry access. Typhoon-related transport suspensions and boundary-crossing closures during Mangkhut show how access can be lost even when buildings are intact.

People, safety and sector-specific threats

Fire, crowd incidents at large venues such as Cotai Arena or a theatre, and security incidents are low-frequency, high-impact events. Loss of key personnel or scarce skills is a further concern; SANDS' earlier sustainability reporting noted that it competes for limited labour in Macao. Regulatory shocks, including enforcement action or reputational damage linked to gaming compliance and anti-money laundering duties, complete the picture.

Practical Tools

Sample likelihood and impact scales

Table 9.1 and Table 9.2 give illustrative scales for SANDS to adapt. They use a five-point range, and the scale bands are shown after Table 9.2.

Table 9.1: Illustrative Likelihood Scale

Score Level Description (illustrative)
1 Rare Not expected within ten years
2 Unlikely Could occur once in five to ten years
3 Possible Could occur once in two to five years
4 Likely Expected about once in one to two years
5 Almost certain Expected more than once a year

Table 9.2: Illustrative Impact Scale for an Integrated Resort

Score Guest and team safety Regulatory and concession Service continuity Financial and reputation
1 Minor No injury No regulatory interest Brief, local disruption Negligible
2 Moderate Minor injuries Informal regulator query One area down for hours Limited, short-lived
3 Significant Several injuries Formal notification and review One resort function down for a day Noticeable media attention
4 Major Serious injuries Investigation or sanction risk Resort-wide disruption for days Sustained adverse coverage
5 Severe Fatalities or mass-casualty risk Threat to concession standing Multi-resort disruption for a prolonged period Severe, lasting harm

The overall score is likelihood multiplied by impact. In this illustration, 1 to 4 is Low, 5 to 9 is Medium, 10 to 15 is High, and 16 to 25 is Critical.

Threat-identification checklist

Workshop facilitators can use the following prompts to test whether a threat has been missed:

  • Which typhoon, flooding or storm-surge scenarios could affect each resort and its utilities?
  • Which activities would stop if power, water or telecommunications failed for 24 hours or more?
  • Which systems have a single point of failure, and who can restore them?
  • Which suppliers, tenants or group shared services would halt an activity if they failed?
  • What if a government order closed gaming, hotels or venues at short notice?
  • Could guests and team members reach and leave the resorts if access routes closed?
  • What would a cyber attack or data breach affect, and who must be notified?
  • Which roles are held by one person with no trained alternate?
  • Which crowd, fire or security events could occur at large venues?
  • Which events could damage trust with the regulator, investors or the public?

Risk appetite in practice

Risk appetite is easier to apply when stated in terms operations leaders recognise. Rather than a general statement, SANDS could write short appetite rules for each impact category. For example, it might state that it accepts no risk above a Medium rating where guest or team member safety is at stake, and that any risk that could threaten concession standing must be escalated to the executive sponsor whatever its score.

These rules turn the matrix into a decision tool. A Critical risk goes to the steering committee at once, a High risk needs an approved treatment plan with a date, and a Medium risk can be accepted by its owner with an annual check. The thresholds in this chapter are illustrative and should be set by SANDS' leadership.

Key risk indicators and the review cycle

A register shows risk at a point in time. Key risk indicators show the direction. For SANDS, useful indicators might include the number of unresolved corrective actions from typhoon exercises, the age of the oldest unpatched critical system, the share of critical suppliers with a recent continuity review, and the time taken to reach team members in a notification test.

The review cycle should combine regular and triggered reviews. Regular reviews are quarterly for High and Critical risks and annual for the rest. Triggered reviews follow an incident, a near miss, a change in law or government direction, the opening of a new venue or a major system change. The BCM coordinator records each review so that the register can be shown to auditors and the board.

Linking to enterprise risk and the BIA

The BCM risk assessment should not sit apart from SANDS' enterprise risk management. Using the same scales and categories lets the BCM register feed the corporate risk report, and lets the corporate team see which enterprise risks have continuity consequences. Where a BCM risk appears in both registers, one owner should be accountable.

The assessment also feeds the BIA. Risks identify the scenarios, such as a multi-resort power loss, that the BIA uses to test how impact grows over time. In turn, the BIA's findings can raise or lower a risk's impact rating. This loop is why the two exercises are best run close together, with the same participants.

Common pitfalls

Several weaknesses recur in risk assessments. Registers sometimes list hundreds of low-value risks and bury the few that matter. Ratings can be copied from another organisation's matrix without evidence. Treatments may be recorded but never funded. Risk owners may be named without their agreement.

The remedies are simple. Keep the register focused on risks to prioritised activities, require evidence for ratings, link each treatment to a budget line and a date, and confirm every owner in person. A short, accurate register is more useful to a board than a long, doubtful one.

Worked Example: Typhoon-Related Utility Outage (R2)

This illustrative example takes one SANDS-relevant risk from BIA context to residual risk. All details about SANDS' set-up are hypothetical.

  1. BIA context: hotel accommodation (CBF-3), casino gaming (CBF-1) and utilities management (CBF-10) are high priority. Guest safety must be protected first.
  2. Threat and vulnerability: a severe typhoon damages public power and water supplies. For example, SANDS might find that some building services are not covered by backup generation.
  3. Inherent rating: likelihood 3 (Possible), impact 5 (Severe, given the multi-resort effect and Hato precedent), giving a score of 15, High.
  4. Existing controls (hypothetical): backup generators for essential loads, a fuel stock and a typhoon procedure. Hato showed that generators can function as designed while services are still affected.
  5. Evaluation: the score exceeds the appetite for risks touching guest safety, so treatment is required.
  6. Treatment (reduce): extend generator coverage to guest welfare loads, agree fuel supply terms, store drinking water and test the switchover at each resort. Transfer part of the financial exposure through insurance, to be reviewed with the finance team.
  7. Residual rating: likelihood stays 3, impact falls to 3 (Significant), giving a score of 9, Medium. The risk owner accepts it with a six-monthly review.

Risk matrix

Table 9.3: Illustrative Risk Matrix (Risks R1 to R12)

Likelihood \ Impact 1 Minor 2 Moderate 3 Significant 4 Major 5 Severe
5 Almost certain          
4 Likely       R1  
3 Possible     R7, R8, R10, R12 R4, R11 R2, R3
2 Unlikely         R5, R6, R9
1 Rare          

Presenting results to the risk committee or board

Senior audiences need clarity rather than volume. SANDS' BCM coordinator can present the top five risks, their ratings, owners and treatment status on a single page, with a short narrative of what has changed since the last review. A heat map such as Table 9.3 helps, as does a plain statement of which risks exceed appetite and what decision is needed. Linking each risk to the CBFs it threatens makes the business consequence clear.

Boards also value trend information. Showing how treatment moves a risk from High to Medium over successive reviews demonstrates that the programme works, and highlights where investment is still needed.

Summary Table

Table 9: Assessing Risks and Threats for Sands China Ltd

Ref Threat category Example scenario Affected activities or resources Current rating (L x I) (illustrative) Existing controls (hypothetical) Proposed treatment ISO 22301 clause or regulatory expectation
R1 Natural hazard Typhoon with flooding forces closure of casinos and venues at signal No. 8 CBF-1, CBF-3, CBF-4, CBF-9, CBF-13; people and premises 4 x 4 = 16 Critical Typhoon procedure; evacuation plan Reduce: annual exercise at each resort; flood protection review; guest shelter plan 8.2.3; DICJ and government typhoon directions
R2 Utilities Prolonged power and water outage after a typhoon (Hato precedent) CBF-1, CBF-3, CBF-10; utilities and premises 3 x 5 = 15 High Backup generators; fuel stock Reduce: extend backup coverage; water storage; supply agreements 8.2.3; 8.3; DICJ power-loss direction
R3 Cyber Ransomware encrypts gaming, hotel and payment systems CBF-1, CBF-7, CBF-8, CBF-15, CBF-16; technology and information 3 x 5 = 15 High Security monitoring; backups Reduce: offline backups; cyber exercise; incident reporting steps 8.2.3; Cybersecurity Law incident duties [verify]
R4 Systems failure Failure of core gaming or hotel platform at a single data centre CBF-1, CBF-3, CBF-6, CBF-7; technology 3 x 4 = 12 High Redundant components Reduce: tested failover; remove single points of failure 8.2.3; 8.3
R5 Public health Government order suspends casinos and entertainment (2020 and 2022 precedents) CBF-1, CBF-12, CBF-13, CBF-18, CBF-19 2 x 5 = 10 High Health protocols; remote work capability Reduce: closure and restart plan; welfare arrangements; staged reopening 8.2.3; civil protection and health orders [verify]
R6 Regulatory and legal Enforcement action or sanction against the concession CBF-2, CBF-23, CBF-25 2 x 5 = 10 High Compliance programme; regulatory reporting Reduce: compliance monitoring; escalation to executive team 6.1; 8.2.3; gaming law supervision [verify]
R7 Access and transport Ferry and boundary-crossing suspensions prevent guests and team members arriving CBF-3, CBF-15, CBF-18; people 3 x 3 = 9 Medium Staff transport arrangements Reduce: alternate staffing; guest communication; ferry contingency 8.2.3; 8.4
R8 Suppliers Failure of a key food, equipment or technology supplier CBF-11, CBF-17, CBF-7; suppliers 3 x 3 = 9 Medium Supplier contracts Reduce: critical supplier review; alternative sources; contract terms 8.2.3; 8.3
R9 Safety Fire or crowd incident at a large venue CBF-4, CBF-12, CBF-13, CBF-19 2 x 5 = 10 High Fire systems; crowd procedures Reduce: venue-specific plans; joint exercises with authorities 8.2.3; 8.4.2
R10 People Loss of key personnel or scarce skills during a prolonged disruption CBF-18, CBF-5, CBF-9 3 x 3 = 9 Medium Succession cover in some roles Reduce: named alternates; cross-training 7.2; 8.2.3
R11 Data Breach of guest personal data CBF-8, CBF-15, CBF-23; information 3 x 4 = 12 High Access controls; data policies Reduce: data minimisation; breach response plan; notification procedure 8.2.3; Personal Data Protection Act [verify]
R12 Reputation Adverse publicity after a poorly handled incident CBF-22, CBF-25 3 x 3 = 9 Medium Media protocols Reduce: crisis communication plan; spokesperson training 8.4.3; 7.4

All ratings, controls and treatments are illustrative and need validation through SANDS' own workshops.

x [BCM] [SANDS] Summing Up Banner

Conclusion

A disciplined risk assessment gives SANDS a ranked view of what could interrupt its resorts, services and compliance. Macao's record of typhoons, utility failures and government-ordered closures supplies credible precedents for the highest-rated risks, while the cyber and supplier risks reflect the technology and dependencies of a modern integrated resort. Clause 8.2.3 should be kept distinct from clause 6.1, and the register should link each risk to the CBFs it threatens.

The immediate next steps are to confirm the scales and appetite with senior management, run workshops with resort and department leaders, name risk owners and agree a review cycle. The next chapter turns from threats to what must be protected, by identifying SANDS' critical business functions.

Sources

Continue reading: Chapter 10, Identifying Critical Business Functions for Sands China Ltd, sets out SANDS' 25 critical business functions, the regulatory and governance context for BCM, and the disruption scenarios that test them.

eBook 1: Understanding Your Organisation
C1 C2 (x) C3 (x) C4 (x) C5 (x) C6 (x)
[BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C1] Overview of BCM Case Study [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C2] Understanding Your Organisation [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C3] Establishing Organisational Goals [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C4] Establishing Business Continuity Objectives [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C5] Determining BC Assumptions [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C6] Composing BCM Team
C7 (x) C8 (x) C9 (x) C10 C11 (x) C12 (x)
[BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C7] Analysing Operating Environment [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C8] Implementing the BCM Planning Methodology [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C9] Assessing Risks and Threats [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C10] Identifying Critical Business Functions [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C11] Summary [BCM] [SANDS] [E1] [C12] Back Cover
 

More Information About Business Continuity Management Courses

To learn more about the course and schedule, click the buttons below for BCM-300 Business Continuity Management Implementer [BCM-3] and BCM-5000 Business Continuity Management Expert Implementer [BCM-5].

New call-to-action New call-to-action Register [BL-B-3]*
New call-to-action New call-to-action New call-to-action
FAQ [BL-B-3]

Please feel free to send us a note if you have any questions.

Email to Sales Team [BCM Institute]

 FAQ BL-B-5 BCM-5000
New call-to-action New call-to-action New call-to-action

 


Comments

CTA Banner_OR

CTA Banner_ORA

CTA Banner_BCM

CTA Banner_ITDR

CTA Banner_CM