.
Keeping Care Running: Managing and Implementing Business Continuity Management at Eastern General Hospital
CC Ai Gen_with Cert Logo 1

[BCM] [EGH] [E3] [CORE] [C6] Chapter 6: Mitigation Strategies for Eastern General Hospital

New call-to-actionLorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetuer adipiscing elit, sed diam nonummy nibh euismod tincidunt ut laoreet dolore magna aliquam erat volutpat.
Moh Heng Goh

Introduction

A hospital must decide what it will do about each risk, and how much risk remains afterwards. This chapter sets out the proposed mitigation strategies for Eastern General Hospital (EGH), building on the threats in Chapter 3, the controls in Chapter 4 and the ratings in Chapter 5.

The strategies support business continuity management (BCM) strategy selection under clause 8.3 of ISO 22301. They are proposals for approval by senior management. The ratings and controls are illustrative, and every existing control is assumed and requires validation. Targets keep the impact score of Chapter 5 and change only the likelihood, because controls usually act on how often a threat occurs rather than how severe the outcome would be.

How Strategies Were Chosen

  • Reduce: 24 threats have a reduction strategy, mostly High ratings.
  • Transfer: 6 threats include transfer through insurance or contract terms.
  • Accept and monitor: 7 threats are accepted with monitoring, because their ratings are Moderate and the cost of further control is not justified.

Each strategy names a specific action, so that an owner can plan it. The justification explains why that action is proportionate to the rating.

Mitigation Strategies

Table BCS P1: Mitigation Strategies for Eastern General Hospital

ThreatExisting Controls (assumed, requires validation)Risk RatingRisk LevelRisk Treatment (Residual Risk)Additional Mitigation StrategyJustification for Selected Mitigation Strategy
Flash FloodSite drainage and flood levels designed for the campus (Preventive); Weather alerts monitored by facilities (Detective)6ModerateReduce; target rating 3 (Very Low / Low)Pre-agreed ambulance diversion routes and stockpiled flood barriersLow cost, and it protects the emergency access route.
Severe Thunderstorm and LightningLightning protection and surge protection (Preventive); Uninterruptible power for critical loads (Compensating)9ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 9 (Moderate)Routine testing and storm checklistImpact is manageable with existing protection; effort is better spent elsewhere.
Extreme HeatChiller capacity with redundancy (Preventive); Heat advisory to staff (Directive)9ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 9 (Moderate)Heat protocol for wards and outdoor staffExisting cooling is adequate for expected conditions.
Transboundary HazeAir filtration on fresh-air intake (Preventive); Air quality monitoring (Detective)6ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 6 (Moderate)Mask stock and a surge plan for respiratory casesPredictable and slow-moving; existing controls suffice.
Pandemic-Related Movement RestrictionsInfectious disease preparedness plan (Directive); Isolation capacity in design (Preventive)10HighReduce; target rating 5 (Moderate)Surge and cohorting plan, stockpile rotation and exerciseSevere consequences justify investment despite low likelihood.
Distant Earthquake TremorsStructural design to local standards (Preventive); Tremor response guide (Directive)6ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 6 (Moderate)Inspection procedure and staff briefingRare and low impact.
FireFire detection, sprinklers and compartmentation (Preventive); Fire wardens and evacuation plan (Corrective)10HighReduce and transfer; target rating 5 (Moderate)Exercise horizontal and vertical evacuation; confirm property insurancePatient safety makes this a priority despite low frequency.
Bomb ThreatBag and visitor screening policy (Preventive); Bomb threat procedure (Directive)8ModerateReduce impact and accept residual likelihood; target rating 8 (Moderate)Exercise with police and clinical relocationModerate rating, but reputational and safety effects justify low-cost exercises.
Active AssailantAccess control and CCTV (Preventive); Lockdown protocol (Corrective)5ModerateReduce impact and accept residual likelihood; target rating 5 (Moderate)Regular joint exercises with the policeVery low likelihood; keep as monitored risk with training.
Chemical or Gas LeakChemical storage controls and gas alarms (Preventive); Spill response kits (Corrective)8ModerateReduce impact and accept residual likelihood; target rating 8 (Moderate)Spill drills and gas-detection testsControls are adequate when exercised.
Structural or Building Services FailurePlanned preventive maintenance (Preventive); Engineering inspections (Detective)5ModerateReduce impact and accept residual likelihood; target rating 5 (Moderate)Alternate ward capacity mapVery low likelihood; monitor.
Major Road or Public Transport DisruptionShuttle and shift handover rules (Compensating); Traffic updates to staff (Detective)9ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 9 (Moderate)Staff travel alerts and shuttleImpact is short-lived.
Infectious Disease OutbreakInfection control policy and isolation rooms (Preventive); Surveillance by infection control team (Detective)15HighReduce; target rating 10 (High)Outbreak exercise and staffing surge poolPatient safety and regulator interest.
Mass Staff IllnessCross-trained staff roster (Compensating); Staff health screening (Preventive)10HighReduce impact and accept residual likelihood; target rating 10 (High)Staffing matrix and reserve poolModerate-high rating warrants simple preparation.
Loss of Key Clinical PersonnelSuccession planning (Preventive); Locum agreements (Compensating)12HighReduce; target rating 8 (Moderate)Key-person cover list and locum frameworkModerate disruption but credible likelihood.
Healthcare Manpower ShortageRecruitment pipeline (Preventive); Overtime rules (Directive)16HighReduce; target rating 12 (High)Phased ramp-up and retention measuresHighest-probability people risk during opening.
Workplace ViolenceSecurity presence in emergency areas (Preventive); Incident reporting (Detective)12HighReduce; target rating 8 (Moderate)Training and alarm coverageFrequent, so worth reducing.
Staff Fatigue and BurnoutRostering rules (Directive); Staff support service (Corrective)16HighReduce; target rating 12 (High)Rostering and wellbeing programmePersistent condition.
Critical Medical Supplier FailureApproved supplier list (Preventive); Safety stock levels (Compensating)12HighReduce and transfer; target rating 8 (Moderate)Dual sourcing and contract continuity clausesReduces single-point dependency.
Pharmaceutical Stock-outMedicine stock monitoring (Detective); Therapeutic substitution protocol (Compensating)15HighReduce; target rating 10 (High)Critical medicine list with buffer and alternatesDirect patient harm potential.
Cloud Service Provider FailureService level agreement with provider (Directive); Offline downtime procedures (Compensating)10HighReduce and transfer; target rating 5 (Moderate)Failover design and contractual recovery targetsTechnology dependency is rising.
Telecommunications Provider FailureDiverse carrier links (Preventive); Radio back-up (Compensating)8ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 8 (Moderate)Carrier diversity checkExisting diversity adequate.
Water Supply FailureOn-site water storage (Compensating); Utility contact list (Directive)5ModerateAccept and monitor; target rating 5 (Moderate)Tanker agreementLow likelihood.
Outsourced Service Provider FailureContract service levels (Directive); Alternate contractor list (Compensating)9ModerateReduce and transfer; target rating 6 (Moderate)Contractor continuity requirementsCommon and manageable.
Ransomware AttackEndpoint protection and email filtering (Preventive); Offline backups (Corrective)15HighReduce and transfer; target rating 10 (High)Immutable backups and cyber exercise; confirm cyber insuranceHighest consequence technology threat.
Power FailureStandby generators and uninterruptible power (Compensating); Power monitoring (Detective)10HighReduce; target rating 5 (Moderate)Regular on-load tests and fuel supply contractPower is fundamental to patient life support.
Electronic Medical Record System FailureSystem redundancy (Preventive); Downtime forms (Compensating)15HighReduce; target rating 10 (High)Downtime drills and read-only replicaFrequent dependence.
Medical Equipment FailureMaintenance contracts (Preventive); Spare equipment pool (Compensating)12HighReduce; target rating 8 (Moderate)Loaner agreements and sparesModerately frequent.
Network and Data Centre OutageRedundant core network (Preventive); Secondary data hall (Compensating)10HighReduce; target rating 5 (Moderate)Failover testsSingle point of failure for many functions.
Air-Conditioning and Ventilation FailureRedundant chillers (Preventive); Temperature alarms (Detective)8ModerateReduce; target rating 4 (Very Low / Low)Spot cooling planTheatres rely on ventilation.
Data Breach or Insider MisuseRole-based access and logging (Preventive); Staff privacy training (Directive)15HighReduce and transfer; target rating 10 (High)Access review, monitoring and breach notification drillRegulatory and reputational exposure.

What the Targets Mean

Of the 17 High threats, 9 fall below High if the strategies work as planned. The other 8 remain High at target: Infectious Disease Outbreak, Mass Staff Illness, Healthcare Manpower Shortage, Staff Fatigue and Burnout, Pharmaceutical Stock-out, Ransomware Attack, Electronic Medical Record System Failure, Data Breach or Insider Misuse. For these, further treatment or a formal risk acceptance by senior management is needed, because the hospital cannot reduce them further with the actions in the table alone.

Implementation Roadmap

The roadmap groups the strategies by timeframe using the priorities from Chapter 4. Owners are the lead owners only; supporting teams are agreed during planning.

Table BCS P1-R: Implementation Roadmap for Eastern General Hospital (lead owners)

TimeframePriorityNumber of ThreatsThreatsLead Owners
0–6 monthsPriority 17Infectious Disease Outbreak, Healthcare Manpower Shortage, Staff Fatigue and Burnout, Pharmaceutical Stock-out, Ransomware Attack, Electronic Medical Record System Failure, Data Breach or Insider MisuseChief Information Officer; Chief Information Security Officer; Chief Pharmacist; Director, Human Resources; Head, Infection Prevention and Control
6–12 monthsPriority 210Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions, Fire, Mass Staff Illness, Loss of Key Clinical Personnel, Workplace Violence, Critical Medical Supplier Failure, Cloud Service Provider Failure, Power Failure, Medical Equipment Failure, Network and Data Centre OutageChief Information Officer; Chief Medical Officer; Director, Facilities and Engineering; Director, Human Resources; Head, Biomedical Engineering; Head, Infection Prevention and Control; Head, Procurement; Head, Security
12–24 monthsPriority 314Flash Flood, Severe Thunderstorm and Lightning, Extreme Heat, Transboundary Haze, Distant Earthquake Tremors, Bomb Threat, Active Assailant, Chemical or Gas Leak, Structural or Building Services Failure, Major Road or Public Transport Disruption, Telecommunications Provider Failure, Water Supply Failure, Outsourced Service Provider Failure, Air-Conditioning and Ventilation FailureChief Information Officer; Chief Nurse; Director, Facilities and Engineering; Head, Procurement; Head, Security

Next Steps for the Hospital

  1. Validate: owners confirm existing controls and evidence listed in Chapter 4.
  2. Approve: senior management approves the strategies, the targets and any risk acceptance.
  3. Plan: each owner converts the strategy into a funded action with a date.
  4. Exercise: the hospital tests the strategies before opening and updates the ratings.
  5. Review: the business continuity steering group reviews progress at least every quarter.

Conclusion

The mitigation strategies show how EGH plans to move its risk profile towards an acceptable level, and where management must still decide. They do not mean that controls are already in place: each one is a plan awaiting validation, funding and testing.

With the minimum objectives, the services they protect, the threats and the strategies defined, the hospital has the core inputs for its continuity plans.

Continue reading: explore BCM Institute's ISO 22301 courses and certifications at blog.bcm-institute.org/certification, and learn how to turn these strategies into tested continuity plans.


Comments

CTA Banner_OR

CTA Banner_ORA

CTA Banner_BCM

CTA Banner_ITDR

CTA Banner_CM