.
Keeping Care Running: Managing and Implementing Business Continuity Management at Eastern General Hospital
CC Ai Gen_with Cert Logo 1

[BCM] [EGH] [E3] [RAR] [P3] Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment for Eastern General Hospital

New call-to-action

The risk analysis and review (RAR) work so far listed what could go wrong at Eastern General Hospital (EGH). Chapters 3 and 4 covered the threats and the assumed controls. This chapter asks how bad each threat could be, and how likely it is. The answers turn a list of threats into a ranked set of risks that management can act on.

Banner [BCM] [E3] [RAR] [T3] Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment

Moh Heng Goh

New call-to-action

[BCM] [E3] [RAR] [T1] [T2] [T3] Template

Part 3: RAR - Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment

Banner [BCM] [E3] [RAR] [T3] Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment

Introduction

The risk analysis and review (RAR) work so far listed what could go wrong at Eastern General Hospital (EGH). Chapters 3 and 4 covered the threats and the assumed controls. This chapter asks how bad each threat could be, and how likely it is. The answers turn a list of threats into a ranked set of risks that management can act on.

The assessment supports the risk assessment in clause 8.2.3 of ISO 22301 and uses the [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [RAR] [T3] Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessmentprinciples of ISO 31000. It represents the current exposure of EGH after the assumed existing controls in Chapter 4 but before any planned control is implemented. The scores are indicative, are not confirmed risk ratings, and must be validated by risk owners and senior management. They support judgement and do not replace it.

Scoring Method

Each threat is scored from 1 to 5 across seven impact areas: finance, operations, legal and regulatory, reputation and image, social responsibility, people, and assets, information technology (IT) systems and information. For a hospital, social responsibility covers patient safety, public health and the effect on the community, including the co-located Eastern Community Hospital.

Table RAR P3-S: Impact and Likelihood Scales for Eastern General Hospital

Score Impact Descriptor Meaning Likelihood Descriptor
1 Very Low (Insignificant) Routine operations absorb it 1 – Rare
2 Low (Minor) Limited, manageable effect 2 – Unlikely
3 Moderate Material but manageable; needs coordinated management 3 – Possible
4 High (Major) Critical services or obligations significantly affected 4 – Likely
5 Very High (Severe) Hospital's ability to deliver essential care is threatened 5 – Almost certain

The risk rating equals the highest impact score multiplied by the likelihood score. The rating is placed in one of four bands.

Table RAR P3-L: Risk Level Bands for Eastern General Hospital

Rating Risk Level
1–4 Very Low / Low
5–9 Moderate
10–16 High
17–25 Very High (Extreme)

Impact Assessment

The table gives the seven impact scores for each threat, followed by the highest score and the areas that produce it. Where areas tie, all are listed.

Table RAR P3: Risk Impact Assessment for Eastern General Hospital

Threat Finance Operations Legal and Regulatory Reputation and Image Social Responsibility People Assets, IT Systems and Information Highest Impact Score and Area
Flash Flood 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 3 – Finance; Operations; Reputation and Image; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Severe Thunderstorm and Lightning 2 3 2 2 2 2 3 3 – Operations; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Extreme Heat 2 3 2 2 3 3 2 3 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Transboundary Haze 2 3 2 2 3 3 2 3 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions 4 4 4 4 5 5 3 5 – Social Responsibility; People
Distant Earthquake Tremors 2 2 3 2 2 3 3 3 – Legal and Regulatory; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Fire 5 4 4 4 5 5 5 5 – Finance; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Bomb Threat 3 4 3 4 4 4 2 4 – Operations; Reputation and Image; Social Responsibility; People
Active Assailant 3 4 3 5 4 5 2 5 – Reputation and Image; People
Chemical or Gas Leak 3 4 3 3 4 4 3 4 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Structural or Building Services Failure 4 4 3 4 4 4 5 5 – Assets, IT Systems and Information
Major Road or Public Transport Disruption 2 3 2 2 3 3 2 3 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Infectious Disease Outbreak 4 4 4 4 5 5 2 5 – Social Responsibility; People
Mass Staff Illness 3 4 3 3 4 5 2 5 – People
Loss of Key Clinical Personnel 3 4 2 3 4 4 2 4 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Healthcare Manpower Shortage 4 4 3 3 4 4 2 4 – Finance; Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Workplace Violence 2 3 3 3 3 4 2 4 – People
Staff Fatigue and Burnout 3 3 3 3 4 4 2 4 – Social Responsibility; People
Critical Medical Supplier Failure 4 4 3 3 4 4 3 4 – Finance; Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Pharmaceutical Stock-out 3 4 3 3 5 4 2 5 – Social Responsibility
Cloud Service Provider Failure 3 4 3 3 3 3 5 5 – Assets, IT Systems and Information
Telecommunications Provider Failure 3 4 2 3 3 3 4 4 – Operations; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Water Supply Failure 3 5 3 3 4 4 3 5 – Operations
Outsourced Service Provider Failure 3 3 3 3 3 3 2 3 – Finance; Operations; Legal and Regulatory; Reputation and Image; Social Responsibility; People
Ransomware Attack 5 5 5 5 5 4 5 5 – Finance; Operations; Legal and Regulatory; Reputation and Image; Social Responsibility; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Power Failure 4 5 3 4 5 5 4 5 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People
Electronic Medical Record System Failure 3 4 3 3 4 3 5 5 – Assets, IT Systems and Information
Medical Equipment Failure 3 4 3 3 4 4 4 4 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Network and Data Centre Outage 4 5 3 4 4 3 5 5 – Operations; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Air-Conditioning and Ventilation Failure 3 4 3 3 4 4 4 4 – Operations; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information
Data Breach or Insider Misuse 4 3 5 5 3 2 5 5 – Legal and Regulatory; Reputation and Image; Assets, IT Systems and Information

Likelihood, Rating and Expected Disruption

Likelihood is assessed separately from impact. The expected period of disruption is the credible duration of the operational interruption under the assumed controls. It is not the recovery time objective (RTO), which is a target, nor the maximum tolerable period of disruption (MTPD), which is a limit.

Table RAR P3B: Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment for Eastern General Hospital

Threat Risk Likelihood Risk Rating Risk Level Expected Period of Disruption
Flash Flood 2 – Unlikely 3 × 2 = 6 Moderate 4–8 hours
Severe Thunderstorm and Lightning 3 – Possible 3 × 3 = 9 Moderate 1–4 hours
Extreme Heat 3 – Possible 3 × 3 = 9 Moderate 1–3 days
Transboundary Haze 2 – Unlikely 3 × 2 = 6 Moderate 1–3 days
Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High More than 1 month
Distant Earthquake Tremors 2 – Unlikely 3 × 2 = 6 Moderate 1–4 hours
Fire 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High 1–3 days
Bomb Threat 2 – Unlikely 4 × 2 = 8 Moderate 4–8 hours
Active Assailant 1 – Rare 5 × 1 = 5 Moderate 8–24 hours
Chemical or Gas Leak 2 – Unlikely 4 × 2 = 8 Moderate 4–8 hours
Structural or Building Services Failure 1 – Rare 5 × 1 = 5 Moderate 3–7 days
Major Road or Public Transport Disruption 3 – Possible 3 × 3 = 9 Moderate 1–4 hours
Infectious Disease Outbreak 3 – Possible 5 × 3 = 15 High 2–4 weeks
Mass Staff Illness 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High 1–2 weeks
Loss of Key Clinical Personnel 3 – Possible 4 × 3 = 12 High 2–4 weeks
Healthcare Manpower Shortage 4 – Likely 4 × 4 = 16 High More than 1 month
Workplace Violence 3 – Possible 4 × 3 = 12 High 1–4 hours
Staff Fatigue and Burnout 4 – Likely 4 × 4 = 16 High More than 1 month
Critical Medical Supplier Failure 3 – Possible 4 × 3 = 12 High 1–2 weeks
Pharmaceutical Stock-out 3 – Possible 5 × 3 = 15 High 1–2 weeks
Cloud Service Provider Failure 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High 4–8 hours
Telecommunications Provider Failure 2 – Unlikely 4 × 2 = 8 Moderate 1–4 hours
Water Supply Failure 1 – Rare 5 × 1 = 5 Moderate 4–8 hours
Outsourced Service Provider Failure 3 – Possible 3 × 3 = 9 Moderate 1–3 days
Ransomware Attack 3 – Possible 5 × 3 = 15 High 1–2 weeks
Power Failure 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High 1–4 hours
Electronic Medical Record System Failure 3 – Possible 5 × 3 = 15 High 4–8 hours
Medical Equipment Failure 3 – Possible 4 × 3 = 12 High 1–3 days
Network and Data Centre Outage 2 – Unlikely 5 × 2 = 10 High 8–24 hours
Air-Conditioning and Ventilation Failure 2 – Unlikely 4 × 2 = 8 Moderate 4–8 hours
Data Breach or Insider Misuse 3 – Possible 5 × 3 = 15 High 1–2 weeks

High and Extreme Risk Analysis

Seventeen of 31 threats are rated High and none is rated Very High (Extreme); the other 14 are Moderate. This does not mean the hospital is safe from extreme outcomes. It reflects the assumed controls and the low likelihood of the most severe events.

Table RAR P3-H: High Risk Analysis for Eastern General Hospital

Threat Highest Impact Area Main Consequences Most Significant Existing Control Principal Control Weakness Management Attention
Healthcare Manpower Shortage Finance; Operations; Social Responsibility; People Could delay opening of wards and reduce capacity. Recruitment pipeline Not yet in place: workforce plan and retention programme tied to phased opening Urgent mitigation
Staff Fatigue and Burnout Social Responsibility; People Could raise errors and sickness and drive resignations. Rostering rules Not yet in place: fatigue risk management and wellbeing programme Urgent mitigation
Infectious Disease Outbreak Social Responsibility; People Could close wards, restrict admissions and strain staff. Infection control policy and isolation rooms Not yet in place: outbreak playbook with ward closure rules and rapid cohorting Urgent mitigation
Pharmaceutical Stock-out Social Responsibility Could affect treatment of emergency and critical patients. Medicine stock monitoring Not yet in place: buffer stock and alternative sourcing for listed critical medicines Urgent mitigation
Ransomware Attack Finance; Operations; Legal and Regulatory; Reputation and Image; Social Responsibility; Assets, IT Systems and Information Could halt clinical systems and force manual operations. Endpoint protection and email filtering Not yet in place: network segmentation, immutable backups and a tested cyber recovery plan Urgent mitigation
Electronic Medical Record System Failure Assets, IT Systems and Information Could delay orders, results and medication. System redundancy Not yet in place: downtime playbook with read-only access and data reconciliation Urgent mitigation
Data Breach or Insider Misuse Legal and Regulatory; Reputation and Image; Assets, IT Systems and Information Could breach privacy law and damage public trust. Role-based access and logging Not yet in place: privileged access management and breach response drill Urgent mitigation
Loss of Key Clinical Personnel Operations; Social Responsibility; People Could stop niche services and reduce quality. Succession planning Not yet in place: deputy and cross-cover map for all critical specialties Planned mitigation
Workplace Violence People Could injure staff and cause absences. Security presence in emergency areas Not yet in place: de-escalation training and panic alarm coverage Planned mitigation
Critical Medical Supplier Failure Finance; Operations; Social Responsibility; People Could delay surgery and stop procedures. Approved supplier list Not yet in place: dual-sourcing for critical items and supplier continuity assessments Planned mitigation
Medical Equipment Failure Operations; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information Could stop imaging or life support. Maintenance contracts Not yet in place: equipment criticality list and loaner agreements Planned mitigation
Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions Social Responsibility; People Could limit staff travel, visitor flow and supply deliveries while demand rises. Infectious disease preparedness plan Not yet in place: pandemic playbook with surge beds, cohorting and staff travel passes Planned mitigation
Fire Finance; Social Responsibility; People; Assets, IT Systems and Information Could force phased evacuation of non-ambulant patients and damage plant or records. Fire detection, sprinklers and compartmentation Not yet in place: phased evacuation drills, patient transfer plan and fire-damage recovery contracts Planned mitigation
Mass Staff Illness People Could reduce safe staffing and force service reductions. Cross-trained staff roster Not yet in place: minimum safe staffing matrix and agency back-up Planned mitigation
Cloud Service Provider Failure Assets, IT Systems and Information Could cut access to cloud-hosted records or telehealth. Service level agreement with provider Not yet in place: cloud exit and failover strategy; tested downtime mode Planned mitigation
Power Failure Operations; Social Responsibility; People Could stop life-support equipment and cooling. Standby generators and uninterruptible power Not yet in place: generator load tests, fuel contracts and manual fallbacks Planned mitigation
Network and Data Centre Outage Operations; Assets, IT Systems and Information Could cut all connected systems. Redundant core network Not yet in place: data centre failover exercise Planned mitigation

Analysis by Impact Area

Assets, IT Systems and Information has the most threats scoring 5 (7), followed by Social Responsibility (6) and People (6). Several threats, such as ransomware, power failure and fire, score high in many areas at once, so they need cross-functional investment rather than a single owner.

Table RAR P3-A: Impact Area Analysis for Eastern General Hospital

Impact Area Threats Scoring 5 Threats Scoring 4 Threats Scoring 5 (names)
Finance 2 8 Fire, Ransomware Attack
Operations 4 17 Water Supply Failure, Ransomware Attack, Power Failure, Network and Data Centre Outage
Legal and Regulatory 2 3 Ransomware Attack, Data Breach or Insider Misuse
Reputation and Image 3 7 Active Assailant, Ransomware Attack, Data Breach or Insider Misuse
Social Responsibility 6 14 Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions, Fire, Infectious Disease Outbreak, Pharmaceutical Stock-out, Ransomware Attack and others
People 6 13 Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions, Fire, Active Assailant, Infectious Disease Outbreak, Mass Staff Illness and others
Assets, IT Systems and Information 7 4 Fire, Structural or Building Services Failure, Cloud Service Provider Failure, Ransomware Attack, Electronic Medical Record System Failure and others
  • Delayed impacts: regulatory action and loss of public trust after a data breach may emerge weeks after the event.
  • Continuing impacts: backlogs of postponed surgery and clinics continue after services resume.
  • Amplifiers: dependence on a single network, data centre or supplier can turn a local fault into a hospital-wide event.

Likelihood and Expected Disruption Analysis

  • Highest likelihood: Healthcare Manpower Shortage, Staff Fatigue and Burnout.
  • Low likelihood but severe: Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions, Fire, Active Assailant, Structural or Building Services Failure, Mass Staff Illness, Cloud Service Provider Failure, Water Supply Failure, Power Failure, Network and Data Centre Outage.
  • Prolonged disruption (two weeks or more): Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions, Infectious Disease Outbreak, Loss of Key Clinical Personnel, Healthcare Manpower Shortage, Staff Fatigue and Burnout.
  • Dependent on external parties: Critical Medical Supplier Failure, Pharmaceutical Stock-out, Cloud Service Provider Failure, Telecommunications Provider Failure, Outsourced Service Provider Failure, Water Supply Failure, Power Failure.
  • Needing early warning: weather-related threats, outbreaks and cyber threats benefit from monitoring and alerts.

A threat of moderate likelihood can still need urgent action where the impact is severe or the disruption is long, because the hospital cannot rebuild trust, staff or stock quickly once the event has happened.

Risk Prioritisation

Threats are ranked by risk level and rating, then by the severity of legal, social and people impact, then by the expected duration. A lower-rated threat with safety implications, such as an active assailant, is kept in the list with a crisis management response so that it is not ignored.

Table RAR P3A: Risk Prioritisation for Eastern General Hospital

Priority Rank Threat Highest Impact Area Likelihood Risk Rating Risk Level Expected Disruption Period Recommended Management Response
1 Healthcare Manpower Shortage Finance (and 3 tied) 4 – Likely 16 High More than 1 month Immediate mitigation; detailed business continuity strategy
2 Staff Fatigue and Burnout Social Responsibility (and 1 tied) 4 – Likely 16 High More than 1 month Immediate mitigation; detailed business continuity strategy
3 Infectious Disease Outbreak Social Responsibility (and 1 tied) 3 – Possible 15 High 2–4 weeks Immediate mitigation; detailed business continuity strategy
4 Pharmaceutical Stock-out Social Responsibility 3 – Possible 15 High 1–2 weeks Immediate mitigation; supplier continuity assurance
5 Ransomware Attack Finance (and 5 tied) 3 – Possible 15 High 1–2 weeks Immediate mitigation; IT disaster recovery enhancement
6 Data Breach or Insider Misuse Legal and Regulatory (and 2 tied) 3 – Possible 15 High 1–2 weeks Immediate mitigation; IT disaster recovery enhancement
7 Electronic Medical Record System Failure Assets, IT Systems and Information 3 – Possible 15 High 4–8 hours Immediate mitigation; IT disaster recovery enhancement
8 Loss of Key Clinical Personnel Operations (and 2 tied) 3 – Possible 12 High 2–4 weeks Detailed business continuity strategy
9 Critical Medical Supplier Failure Finance (and 3 tied) 3 – Possible 12 High 1–2 weeks Supplier continuity assurance
10 Medical Equipment Failure Operations (and 3 tied) 3 – Possible 12 High 1–3 days Detailed business continuity strategy
11 Workplace Violence People 3 – Possible 12 High 1–4 hours Detailed business continuity strategy
12 Pandemic-Related Movement Restrictions Social Responsibility (and 1 tied) 2 – Unlikely 10 High More than 1 month Detailed business continuity strategy
13 Mass Staff Illness People 2 – Unlikely 10 High 1–2 weeks Detailed business continuity strategy
14 Fire Finance (and 3 tied) 2 – Unlikely 10 High 1–3 days Crisis management scenario development
15 Power Failure Operations (and 2 tied) 2 – Unlikely 10 High 1–4 hours Detailed business continuity strategy
16 Network and Data Centre Outage Operations (and 1 tied) 2 – Unlikely 10 High 8–24 hours IT disaster recovery enhancement
17 Cloud Service Provider Failure Assets, IT Systems and Information 2 – Unlikely 10 High 4–8 hours Supplier continuity assurance
18 Extreme Heat Operations (and 2 tied) 3 – Possible 9 Moderate 1–3 days Routine monitoring
19 Outsourced Service Provider Failure Finance (and 5 tied) 3 – Possible 9 Moderate 1–3 days Routine monitoring
20 Major Road or Public Transport Disruption Operations (and 2 tied) 3 – Possible 9 Moderate 1–4 hours Crisis management scenario development
21 Severe Thunderstorm and Lightning Operations (and 1 tied) 3 – Possible 9 Moderate 1–4 hours Routine monitoring
22 Bomb Threat Operations (and 3 tied) 2 – Unlikely 8 Moderate 4–8 hours Crisis management scenario development
23 Chemical or Gas Leak Operations (and 2 tied) 2 – Unlikely 8 Moderate 4–8 hours Crisis management scenario development
24 Air-Conditioning and Ventilation Failure Operations (and 3 tied) 2 – Unlikely 8 Moderate 4–8 hours Routine monitoring
25 Telecommunications Provider Failure Operations (and 1 tied) 2 – Unlikely 8 Moderate 1–4 hours Routine monitoring
26 Transboundary Haze Operations (and 2 tied) 2 – Unlikely 6 Moderate 1–3 days Routine monitoring
27 Flash Flood Finance (and 5 tied) 2 – Unlikely 6 Moderate 4–8 hours Routine monitoring
28 Distant Earthquake Tremors Legal and Regulatory (and 2 tied) 2 – Unlikely 6 Moderate 1–4 hours Routine monitoring
29 Active Assailant Reputation and Image (and 1 tied) 1 – Rare 5 Moderate 8–24 hours Crisis management scenario development
30 Structural or Building Services Failure Assets, IT Systems and Information 1 – Rare 5 Moderate 3–7 days Crisis management scenario development
31 Water Supply Failure Operations 1 – Rare 5 Moderate 4–8 hours Routine monitoring

Management Validation

  1. Owner review: threat owners and function owners confirm the scores and the controls they rely on.
  2. Specialist input: IT, security, facilities, human resources and procurement test the assumptions in their areas.
  3. Challenge: risk management and business continuity management challenge scores that look too low or too high.
  4. Evidence: scores are checked against incident data, threat intelligence and exercise results.
  5. Approval: senior management approves the scores through the hospital's risk governance process and records any override.
  6. Review: scores are refreshed at least yearly and after incidents, exercises or major changes.

New call-to-action

Impact and likelihood scoring turns the Threat Register of EGH into prioritised risk information. The highest impact score and likelihood give the rating, but professional judgement still decides how it is used. The 17 High threats, listed in Table RAR P3-H and ranked in Table RAR P3A, should drive mitigation and continuity investment.

A risk assessment must show not only which threats may occur, but also how severe the consequences are, how likely they are and how long they could disrupt the essential services of the hospital. The next chapter sets out the mitigation strategies that follow.

Continue reading: Chapter 6, Mitigation Strategies for Eastern General Hospital, sets residual risk targets and mitigation strategies for each threat.

 

 

 

New call-to-action

eBook 3: Starting Your BCM Implementation
MBCO P&S  RAR T1 RAR T2 RAR T3 BCS T1  CBF
New call-to-action [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [PS] Key Product and Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [RAR] [T1] List of Threats [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [RAR] [T2] Treatment and Control [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [RAR] [T3] Risk Impact and Likelihood Assessment [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BCS] [T1] Mitigation Strategies and Justification [BCM] [EGH] [E1] [C10] Identifying Critical Business Functions
CBF-1 Emergency Department Services
DP BIAQ P1 BIAQ P2 BIAQ P3 BIAQ P4 BIAQ P5 BIAQ P6
[BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [DP] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T1] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T2] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T3] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T4] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T5] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BIA] [T6] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services
    BCS T2 BCS T3 PD    
    [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BCS] [T2] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [BCS] [T3] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services [BCM] [EGH] [E3] [PD] [CBF] [1] Emergency Department Services  

Comments

CTA Banner_OR

CTA Banner_ORA

CTA Banner_BCM

CTA Banner_ITDR

CTA Banner_CM