Under an operational resilience lens, its scope widens: the board must say how much disruption to clients, to the bank and to the market it will tolerate.
The Confirm Risk Appetite stage of the Plan phase asks Bank Julius Baer (BJB) to state this clearly and to link it to measures that management can monitor.
After reading this chapter, you should be able to distinguish risk appetite, risk tolerance and risk threshold, carry out the three implementation steps, and draft an operational resilience paragraph for the bank's risk appetite statement. It is relevant to board members, the chief risk officer and the OR lead.
Risk appetite is board-approved and strategic. Risk tolerance varies by objective and sets the acceptable deviation. A risk threshold is a quantitative maximum. Appetite can be expressed qualitatively (high, medium, low) or quantitatively, and should reflect the bank's business model, objectives and strategy. It also sets boundaries for opportunity-seeking behaviour.
Identify and evaluate threats and vulnerabilities to operations, internal and external: cyber threats, natural events, supply chain disruption, and regulatory change.
Illustrative example: BJB Singapore rates a cyber attack on a payments provider and a prolonged loss of a data centre as the two highest operational disruption risks, because both affect several client services at once.
Assess the likelihood and impact of disruption to determine acceptable exposure. Use measures that management can track: hours of downtime, number of clients affected, value of delayed transactions.
Illustrative example: the bank decides that a delay of more than a business day in releasing client payment instructions is outside tolerance, and that more than a stated number of affected clients triggers escalation to the executive committee.
Write the statement in plain language, align it with the wider risk appetite framework and make it usable by managers when they take decisions.
Illustrative wording: "The Bank has low appetite for disruption to services that clients rely on for payments, settlement and access to assets. It will invest to keep these services within approved impact tolerances and will report any breach to the board."
Add key risk indicators tied to resilience drivers, such as the proportion of critical services with tested recovery, the age of the last test, open remediation actions past due, and the number of material third parties without exit plans. The board should review these metrics at least once a year. Where Group appetite is set elsewhere, state how the Singapore statement relates to it [verify].
An appetite statement is read by directors, managers and, in time, supervisors. It should therefore be short, free of jargon and linked to a few measures. It should say what the bank will protect (for example, the services clients rely on), the level of disruption it will accept (low, medium or high), and what it will do if the appetite is breached. It should avoid language that cannot be tested, such as "minimise disruption wherever possible".
Illustrative statement structure for BJB Singapore:
People often confuse the three terms. Appetite is the board's general willingness to accept risk. Tolerance is the acceptable deviation for a specific objective. A threshold is the numerical trigger. For example, the board's low appetite for client-payment disruption (appetite) is translated into a same-day release requirement (tolerance), with an escalation trigger when more than a set number of payments are delayed beyond a cut-off (threshold). Writing all three for one service in a single table helps managers see how they connect.
Review the statement at least annually and after any severe incident. The second line should challenge whether the indicators measure what matters, and whether the board has acted on reported breaches. Where the bank belongs to a wider group, show how the Singapore statement relates to the group statement and who approves any difference [verify].
| Step | Activity | Output |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Conduct risk assessment | Rated disruption risks |
| 2 | Quantify risk tolerance | Measurable thresholds |
| 3 | Define appetite statement | Board-approved statement and indicators |
A clear appetite statement gives managers a boundary and gives the board something to hold them to. For BJB it prepares the ground for impact tolerances in the Implement phase. The last stage of Plan puts the structures in place to make decisions and report on them.
Continue reading: Chapter 7, Developing and Embedding Governance of OR Plan Phase for Bank Julius Baer, defines who is accountable.
| eBook 2: Implementing Operational Resilience for Bank Julius Baer |
|||
| C1 | C2 | C8 | C14 |
| "Plan" Phase of the Operational Resilience Planning Methodology |
||||||
| C2 | C3 | C4 | C5 | C6 | C7 | |