---
title: "[OR] [BJB] [E2] [C19] Conducting Independent Quality Review of OR Sustain Phase for Bank Julius Baer"
description: How Bank Julius Baer can commission an independent quality review of its resilience programme, using the three lines model and a red-flag checklist.
image: https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/BJB%20Graphic%20Folder/BJB%20Morepost/BJB%20E2%20Morepost/%5BOR%5D%20%5BBJB%5D%20%5BE2%5D%20%5BP3%5D%20%5BS5%5D%20%5BC19%5D%20Conducting%20Independent%20Quality%20Reviews.jpg
---

[![BCMIWhiteLogo.png](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog%20Testing/BCMIWhiteLogo.png?width=556&name=BCMIWhiteLogo.png "BCMIWhiteLogo.png")](http://www.bcm-institute.org/)

- [Home](https://www.bcm-institute.org/)
- [About Us](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us-3/) 
    - [A President’s Perspective](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/a-presidents-perspective/)
    - [Our History](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/our-history/)
    - [Our Advisory Council](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/our-advisory-council/)
    - [Customers’ Testimonials](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/customers-testimonials/)
    - [Credential Verification](https://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/credential-verification/)
- [Courses](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/blog/course-fees-for-blended-learning-courses-master-catalog) 
    - [ISO 22301 Business Continuity Management System Audit](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/audit/business-continuity-management-audit-courses)
    - [ISO 22301 Business Continuity Management](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/bcm/business-continuity-management-courses)
    - [Crisis Communication](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/crisis-communication/crisis-communication-courses)
    - [Crisis Management](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/en/crisis-management/courses)
    - [IT Disaster Recovery](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/it-disaster-recovery/courses)
    - [Operational Resilience](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/operational-resilience/courses)
    - [Operational Resilience Audit](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/operational-resilience-audit/courses)
- [Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/certification/types-of-certifications-offered) 
    - [ISO 22301 BCMS Audit Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/certification/business-continuity-management-audit-certification)
    - [ISO22301 Business Continuity Management Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/bcm/business-continuity-management-certification)
    - [Crisis Communication Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/crisis-communication/crisis-communication-certification)
    - [Crisis Management Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/en/crisis-management/crisis-management-certification)
    - [IT Disaster Recovery Planning Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/it-disaster-recovery/it-disaster-recovery-certification)
    - [Operational Resilience Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/operational-resilience/operational-resilience-certification)
    - [Operational Resilience Audit Certification](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/operational-resilience-audit)
- [Seminars](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/meet-the-expert/mte-webinar-mainpage)
- [Store](https://www.bcm-institute.org/store-2/)
- [Contact Us](http://www.bcm-institute.org/about-us/contact-us/)

- <https://www.facebook.com/BCMInstitute/>
- <https://www.linkedin.com/company/business-continuity-management-institute-bcm-institute>

###### Building Operational Resilience at Bank Julius Baer: A Strategic Implementation Guide

![\[BB\] \[FSI\] Cybersecurity Operations\_ Global Threat Map](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hs-fs/hubfs/BB%20FSI_Bank/%5BBB%5D%20%5BFSI%5D%20Cybersecurity%20Operations_%20Global%20Threat%20Map.png?width=1672&height=941&name=%5BBB%5D%20%5BFSI%5D%20Cybersecurity%20Operations_%20Global%20Threat%20Map.png "[BB] [FSI] Cybersecurity Operations_ Global Threat Map")

# \[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[C19\] Conducting Independent Quality Review of OR Sustain Phase for Bank Julius Baer

[![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[Full Banner\] Strengthening Banking Resilience A Practical Guide for Bank Julius Baer](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/e929c6dc-a612-428f-b369-59f1b149ace1.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/e929c6dc-a612-428f-b369-59f1b149ace1)A self-assessment is written by the people who run the programme. An independent quality review is written by people who do not.

It is an objective, arm's-length assessment of the operational resilience programme by qualified reviewers using impartial evidence, and it is the last stage of the Sustain phase.

For Bank Julius Baer (BJB) it provides confidence to the board and to the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) that the programme works in practice and not only on paper.

[![\[OR\] \[E2\] \[C19\] \[P3\] \[S5\] Conducting Independent Quality Review](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/ce795037-24ce-4c90-afd2-5253ea9ebb4c.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/ce795037-24ce-4c90-afd2-5253ea9ebb4c)[![\[Logo\] \[OR\] Certification Transparent](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/09ce1ea0-4d44-4deb-867f-2e2b1b867768.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/09ce1ea0-4d44-4deb-867f-2e2b1b867768)

[Moh Heng Goh](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/or-v2/author/moh-heng-goh) Nov 19, 2026

## [![BJB Legal Disclaimer Banner](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/76215f61-1d28-496b-9b19-d5146352e15d.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/76215f61-1d28-496b-9b19-d5146352e15d)

## [![\[OR\] \[E2\] \[C19\] \[P3\] \[S5\] Conducting Independent Quality Review](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/ce795037-24ce-4c90-afd2-5253ea9ebb4c.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/ce795037-24ce-4c90-afd2-5253ea9ebb4c)Introduction

[![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[S5\] \[C19\] Conducting Independent Quality Reviews](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/5011ef56-b909-4aa8-896a-ec9692d979f6.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/5011ef56-b909-4aa8-896a-ec9692d979f6)A self-assessment is written by the people who run the programme. An independent quality review is written by people who do not. It is an objective, arm's-length assessment of the operational resilience programme by qualified reviewers using impartial evidence, and it is the last stage of the Sustain phase. For Bank Julius Baer (BJB) it provides confidence to the board and to the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) that the programme works in practice and not only on paper.

## Purpose of the Chapter

This chapter shows how to commission and run an independent review in three parts: prepare, conduct, and review and report. After reading it you should know who can act as reviewer, how the three lines model shapes scope, what red flags to look for and how to follow up. The examples are illustrative.

## The Three Lines Model

The first line, managers and staff, owns and manages risk and controls. The second line, risk and compliance, oversees and challenges. The third line, internal audit, provides independent assurance on governance, risk management and control. External assurance sits outside the model but supports governance. An independent quality review can be carried out by internal audit, an external auditor, a specialist firm or, in some cases, a regulator.

## Implementation Steps

### Prepare

Determine the scope using the three lines model: the risks, the critical processes, the controls, incident response or the whole programme. Select a reviewer with operational resilience and risk expertise. Set review criteria from good practice, internal standards and regulatory requirements. Assemble documents, reports and test results. Agree scope, objectives and method with the reviewer.

*Illustrative example:* BJB's audit committee asks internal audit to review the programme every two years, with an external specialist supporting the first review.

### Conduct

Carry out observation, interviews and document review. Test controls, incident response plans and training, including through simulations. Compare the evidence with the criteria. Prepare a draft report on strengths, weaknesses and recommendations.

### Review and Report

Management provides a formal response and action plan. The final report goes to senior management and the board. Actions are implemented with owners, timelines and resources, and progress is monitored and reported.

*Illustrative example:* the review recommends that impact tolerances be supported with data from past incidents. Management accepts the recommendation, assigns it to the head of operational risk and sets a date for follow-up.

## Red Flags for Reviewers

- Weak senior-level skills or understanding of resilience
- Unsubstantiated analysis of critical services and required levels of resilience
- Unrealistic scenario assumptions
- Incomplete service registers or asset inventories
- Heavy reliance on end-user computing, such as spreadsheets
- Unexplained swings in probability or impact estimates
- Unclear risk appetite and tolerances
- Inflexible legacy infrastructure
- New regulations that add resilience pressure, such as protection of sensitive client data

## Choosing a Reviewer

The reviewer needs three qualities: independence from the people who built the programme, expertise in operational resilience and enough access to evidence. Internal audit meets the first and third. It may need help with the second, particularly in the first review, from an external specialist. Using an external provider can bring comparison with other institutions, and can give additional comfort to the board. Whoever is chosen, agree the terms of reference in writing, including scope, access, timing, reporting lines and how disagreements will be resolved.

## What a Good Review Looks At

- Whether critical services were identified with defensible criteria and are complete
- Whether maps reflect reality, including third parties and concentration risk
- Whether tolerances are justified and consistent with risk appetite
- Whether scenarios are severe enough and tests are realistic
- Whether remediation is funded, owned and verified
- Whether governance works in practice: do the forum and the board ask hard questions and act on the answers?
- Whether training and communication reach the people who need them

## Responding to Findings

Management should respond to each finding with an agreement or a reasoned disagreement, an owner and a date. The resilience forum tracks the actions, and internal audit follows up on high-rated findings. Share the lessons beyond the programme: a finding about unrealistic scenario assumptions, for example, may apply to stress testing and to business continuity as well. Summarise the outcome for the board and, where appropriate, for the regulator. At the next self-assessment, report on what changed because of the review.

## Summary Table

| **Part** | **Activity** | **Output** |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Prepare** | **Scope, reviewer, criteria, evidence** | **Agreed terms of review** |
| **Conduct** | **Observe, interview, test, compare** | **Draft report** |
| **Review and report** | **Management response and tracking** | **Final report and action plan** |

## [![\[Banner\] \[Summing\] \[OR\] \[E2\] \[C19\] Conducting Independent Quality Reviews](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/c8a957a9-acb3-45ed-98ab-290e94e02707.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/c8a957a9-acb3-45ed-98ab-290e94e02707)Conclusion

The independent review completes the cycle. It tests the evidence, challenges the judgements and gives BJB a fresh view of what to improve. The final chapter summarises the eBook.

## Sources

- [What is Conducting an Independent Quality and Assurance Review in Operational Resilience?](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/operational-resilience/or-p3-s5-conduct-independent-quality-assurance-review-in-operational-resilience), BCM Institute

**Continue reading:** Chapter 20, *Conclusion for eBook 2 for Bank Julius Baer*, summarises the journey.

 

[![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[34 Banner\] Strengthening Banking Resilience A Practical Guide for Bank Julius Baer](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/00cdca0d-a0af-4bc5-972d-ee3caa7a94e4.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/00cdca0d-a0af-4bc5-972d-ee3caa7a94e4)

| **eBook 2: Implementing Operational Resilience for Bank Julius Baer** |  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **C1** | **C2** | **C8** | **C14** |
| [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[C1\] OR Planning Methodology](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/3d6383a7-3d72-453d-a290-961ba27ab5c3.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/3d6383a7-3d72-453d-a290-961ba27ab5c3) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P1\] \[S1-S5\] \[C2\] Five Stages of the \_Plan\_ Phase](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/c8556221-4983-4862-ae1d-469687b348eb.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/c8556221-4983-4862-ae1d-469687b348eb) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P2\] \[S1-S5\] \[C8\] Five Stages of the \_Implement\_ Phase](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/5950274f-db27-46d5-93a8-728b5b0c071c.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/5950274f-db27-46d5-93a8-728b5b0c071c) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[C14\] The Five Stages of the \_Sustain\_ Phase](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/53ad46fa-2ebc-48b0-9ec6-5d5dd7b6d203.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/53ad46fa-2ebc-48b0-9ec6-5d5dd7b6d203) |

 

|  | **"Sustain" Phase of the Operational Resilience Planning Methodology** |  |  |  |  |  |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
|  | **C14** | **C15** | **C16** | **C17** | **C18** | **C19** |
|  | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[C14\] The Five Stages of the \_Sustain\_ Phase](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/53ad46fa-2ebc-48b0-9ec6-5d5dd7b6d203.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/53ad46fa-2ebc-48b0-9ec6-5d5dd7b6d203) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[S1\] \[C15\] Introducing Cultural Change Management](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/e295f1b8-7a10-4220-a6bd-26a3833cc74c.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/e295f1b8-7a10-4220-a6bd-26a3833cc74c) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[S2\] \[C16\] Developing a Communication Strategy](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/8d6e7c50-304e-42c8-b122-63a9148bcdba.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/8d6e7c50-304e-42c8-b122-63a9148bcdba) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[S3\] C17\] Implementing Training and Awareness](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/7b937ee3-fb5b-4506-b23a-5e744cf8dcf8.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/7b937ee3-fb5b-4506-b23a-5e744cf8dcf8) | [![\[OR\] \[BJB\] \[E2\] \[P3\] \[S4\] \[C18\] Providing Self-Assessment](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/3893111/392b1906-ffc3-4d4f-840a-71f3d70f9a78.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/3893111/392b1906-ffc3-4d4f-840a-71f3d70f9a78) |  |

## **Comments**

![CTA Banner\_OR](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/CTA%20Banner%20for%20Blog/CTA%20Banner_OR.jpg "CTA Banner_OR")

---

![CTA Banner\_ORA](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/CTA%20Banner%20for%20Blog/CTA%20Banner_ORA.jpg "CTA Banner_ORA")

---

![CTA Banner\_BCM](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/CTA%20Banner%20for%20Blog/CTA%20Banner_BCM.jpg "CTA Banner_BCM")

---

![CTA Banner\_ITDR](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/CTA%20Banner%20for%20Blog/CTA%20Banner_ITDR.jpg "CTA Banner_ITDR")

---

![CTA Banner\_CM](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/CTA%20Banner%20for%20Blog/CTA%20Banner_CM.jpg "CTA Banner_CM")

![BCMIWhiteLogoSmall.png](https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog%20Testing/BCMIWhiteLogoSmall.png?width=72&name=BCMIWhiteLogoSmall.png "BCMIWhiteLogoSmall.png")

All rights reserved. Copyright 2026

```json
{
  "@context" : "https://schema.org",
  "@type" : "BlogPosting",
  "author" : {
    "@type" : "Person",
    "name" : "Moh Heng Goh",
    "url" : "https://blog.bcm-institute.org/or-v2/author/moh-heng-goh"
  },
  "dateModified" : "2026-11-19T04:03:10.743Z",
  "datePublished" : "2026-11-19T04:03:05.000Z",
  "headline" : "[OR] [BJB] [E2] [C19] Conducting Independent Quality Review of OR Sustain Phase for Bank Julius Baer",
  "image" : [ "https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/BJB%20Graphic%20Folder/BJB%20Morepost/BJB%20E2%20Morepost/%5BOR%5D%20%5BBJB%5D%20%5BE2%5D%20%5BP3%5D%20%5BS5%5D%20%5BC19%5D%20Conducting%20Independent%20Quality%20Reviews.jpg" ],
  "mainEntityOfPage" : {
    "@id" : "https://blog.bcm-institute.org/or-v2/or-bjb-e2-chapter-19-conducting-independent-quality-review-of-or-sustain-phase-for-bank-julius-baer",
    "@type" : "WebPage"
  },
  "publisher" : {
    "@type" : "Organization",
    "logo" : {
      "@type" : "ImageObject",
      "url" : "https://blog.bcm-institute.org/hubfs/BCMI%20Logo.png"
    },
    "name" : "BCMI Pte Ltd"
  }
}
```