BCM v2

[BCM] [EGH] [E2] [C7] Testing and Exercising Phase for Business Continuity Management Planning Methodology for Eastern General Hospital

Written by Moh Heng Goh | Nov 17, 2026, 5:20:38 AM

Introduction

A plan that has never been tested is an assumption. The sixth phase, Testing and Exercising (TE), shows whether the plans written in Chapter 6 work, whether staff can use them, and whether the strategies in Chapter 5 deliver the recovery times set in Chapter 4. For Eastern General Hospital (EGH), exercising also builds confidence among clinical teams, who must trust that continuity arrangements will help rather than hinder patient care.

This chapter groups exercise types into initial tests and advanced tests, explains how an exercise is planned and run, and describes what was found about regulatory requirements for exercising. Scenarios, frequencies and examples are illustrative and must be confirmed by EGH.

Initial Tests

Initial tests are small, low-risk and quick to run. They should be mastered before the larger exercises are attempted, since an advanced exercise built on weak foundations wastes the time of many people.

Component Tests

A component test checks one element of a plan on its own. Examples for a hospital include running the backup generator on load and confirming that automatic changeover works, restoring a clinical database from an offline backup, checking that reserve oxygen manifolds switch correctly, or confirming that a downtime kit contains the forms it should. Component tests are usually owned by the technical team responsible for the element and are suited to risks R1, R2 and R6.

Call Notification Tests

A call notification test checks that the right people can be reached quickly. The mass notification tool sends a message to the recovery organisation and records who responds and how long it takes. The test should be run at different times, including nights and weekends, because contact lists decay and response varies with the hour. Results are measured against a target, for example that a set share of the recovery organisation confirms within fifteen minutes. This test supports risks R8 and R9.

Walkthrough Exercises

In a walkthrough, participants sit together and talk through a scenario step by step, reading their plan as they go. A facilitator introduces events and asks what each role would do. A walkthrough costs little time and finds many gaps: missing contacts, unclear authority, steps that nobody owns. For example, a walkthrough of a sustained power loss (R1) in the critical care plan (CBF-4) might reveal that nobody is named to authorise transfer of patients to another unit.

Advanced Tests

Advanced tests are attempted once the initial tests are routine. They involve more people, more realism and more risk, so they need more preparation.

Integrated Tests

An integrated test combines several plans or functions in one exercise. For example, a scenario of a cyberattack on clinical systems (R2) would involve information technology (CBF-12), the emergency department (CBF-1), pharmacy (CBF-6), laboratory services (CBF-5) and crisis communications (CBF-16). The aim is to find problems at the boundaries between plans, which single-function tests cannot show.

Simulation Tests

A simulation test creates a realistic but safe situation, often with scripted injects delivered over a set period, simulated phone calls and role players. Participants act as they would in a real event while normal services continue. Examples include a mass casualty surge (R9) with simulated patient arrivals and a tabletop simulation of an outbreak cluster (R3) with injects on bed availability, staff absence and media queries.

Live Tests

A live test uses real systems, real people and real conditions. It may involve switching off a power feed under controlled conditions, evacuating a ward, or failing over a clinical system to its secondary site. Live tests give the strongest evidence but carry the highest risk to patients. They need strong safeguards, a clear abort criterion, approval from the clinical lead and often a quiet period in the service. In a hospital, a live test would normally be restricted to non-clinical areas or to periods and locations agreed by the clinical leaders.

How an Exercise Is Planned and Run

  1. Set the objectives. State what the exercise should prove, such as that critical care can switch to reserve gases within the one-hour target.
  2. Choose the type and scenario. Match the exercise to the maturity of the plans, and base the scenario on a risk from the register.
  3. Define scope and rules. Say who takes part, what is in and out, what safety limits apply, and when the exercise will be stopped.
  4. Appoint roles. A director owns the exercise, a facilitator runs it, evaluators watch and record, and a safety officer can halt it.
  5. Prepare materials. Write the scenario, the timeline of injects, evaluation forms and briefing notes.
  6. Brief participants. Make clear that the aim is learning, not blame.
  7. Run the exercise. Record times, decisions and difficulties. Keep patient care first, and stop if patient safety is at risk.
  8. Debrief at once. Gather views while memory is fresh.
  9. Report and act. Write a short report within a week or two, list corrective actions with owners and dates, and track them to completion.

Exercise results feed back into the earlier phases. A failure may point to an unrealistic recovery target in the BIA or a weak strategy, and not only to a poor plan. Chapter 8 describes how these lessons are recorded in the programme.

Staging Exercises for a Hospital Still Being Built

EGH's website states that the hospital will begin serving patients virtually in 2026, with the physical campus due in 2029 to 2030. Exercising should follow that sequence. For the virtual service, component tests of network and platform failover and call notification tests are suitable early steps, followed by a walkthrough of an outage affecting virtual and home care (R10). As physical areas near completion, commissioning tests can include continuity scenarios, for example a controlled power transfer test. Before each physical service opens, a walkthrough should confirm that the plan for that service is ready, and a larger simulation should be considered before the emergency department and critical care open.

Regulatory Requirement for This Phase

The search looked for what the Ministry of Health (MOH) or the law of Singapore requires or expects about testing or exercising continuity or emergency plans for acute hospital services. The pages opened and their results were as follows.

  • Licence conditions for acute hospital service licensees (version 1.0). This document, which binds licensees, sets out specific requirements on premises, patient care, intensive care, emergency department service and other topics. It contains no condition on business continuity plans, emergency plans, drills or exercises. The nearest provision is condition 11.1, which requires licensees providing emergency department service to establish, implement and regularly review policies on deploying qualified personnel promptly, on segregating patients with highly infectious disease or hazardous material contamination, and on prompt resuscitation of time-sensitive conditions. The condition requires review of these policies and does not mention testing or exercises. The text read does not state an effective date.
  • Licence conditions on emergency life saving measures. These conditions require adequate resuscitation drugs and equipment on site, and practitioners competent to use them. They do not require emergency plans, drills or exercises.
  • MOH Circular 87/2023. This circular notified acute and community hospital licensees of licence conditions to be issued. The text read does not refer to emergency preparedness, continuity or exercises.
  • HCSA requirement pages. The pages for licensees in general and for the acute hospital service refer to the Act, regulations, licence conditions and codes of practice, and state that licensees must comply with them. They state that FAQs and guidance illustrate good practice and are not enforceable. They contain no text on emergency preparedness or exercising.
  • The regulations themselves. The Healthcare Services (General) Regulations 2021 and the Healthcare Services (Acute Hospital Service) Regulations 2023 were opened on Singapore Statutes Online, but the pages displayed only the first provisions. Any later provision on emergency planning could not be read. This is marked [verify].

Conclusion on the search: no specific requirement on testing or exercising continuity or emergency plans was found in the licence conditions and pages that could be read, so none is claimed here. Licence conditions are binding on licensees, while FAQs and guidance are not. EGH should ask MOH, and check the full text of the regulations and any group-level requirements from SingHealth, to confirm whether other requirements apply [verify].

In the absence of a specific rule, the nearest relevant standard is ISO 22301, which is the basis of this methodology and which expects an organisation to exercise and test its continuity procedures and to review the results. The text of the standard was not opened for this eBook, and clause references are not given [verify]. Whatever the legal position, regular exercising is the only way to show that recovery times can be met.

Summary Table

Group Exercise type What it proves Illustrative EGH example
Initial Component test One element works Generator changeover on load (R1)
Initial Call notification test People can be reached quickly Night-time alert to the recovery organisation (R8)
Initial Walkthrough Plan steps are clear and owned Power loss in critical care (CBF-4)
Advanced Integrated test Plans work together Cyberattack across CBF-12, CBF-1, CBF-6 (R2)
Advanced Simulation test People can manage a realistic event Mass casualty surge (R9)
Advanced Live test Real systems recover as planned Controlled system failover

Exercising proves or disproves the work of the earlier phases. For EGH, the sensible route is to start with component tests, call notification tests and walkthroughs, to move to integrated, simulation and live tests as plans mature, and to tie each opening stage to an exercise. No specific regulatory requirement on exercising was found in the pages that could be read, so EGH should confirm the position with MOH and rely on ISO 22301 and its own risk rating until it does. The next chapter explains how the programme keeps plans current and records the lessons from each exercise.

Sources

Continue reading: Chapter 8, Program Management Phase for Business Continuity Management Planning Methodology for Eastern General Hospital, which explains governance, review, training, measures, audit and the programme calendar.

 

Keeping Care Running: Managing and Implementing Business Continuity Management at Eastern General Hospital
eBook 2: Implementing Business Continuity Management
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5
C6 C7 C8 C9 C10